Bankruptcy and Diligence (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Bankruptcy and Diligence (Scotland) Bill became the Bankruptcy and Diligence (Scotland) Act 2024. It amends the Bankruptcy (Scotland) Act 2016 and several laws on debt recovery, court orders and the seizure of property. Its stated goal is to establish a mental health moratorium and change bankruptcy and diligence rules; those aims are not guaranteed results.

  • Scottish Ministers must make regulations to establish a moratorium on debt recovery action against some people with a mental illness. The regulations will set eligibility, covered debts, duration and other rules, and must be approved by Parliament.
  • The Accountant in Bankruptcy (AiB) gets new responsibilities in some sequestrations (bankruptcy proceedings), including taking over as trustee in certain long-running cases where the debtor has not co-operated.
  • People seeking recall of sequestration may have to pay interest as well as debts and trustee costs. Interest is not payable if the whole debt is paid within six months of the sequestration award.
  • The Act changes information, notice and time rules for protected trust deeds, debt recovery and the attachment of property. It also allows money attachment at business premises while they are open, without prior sheriff approval.
  • Some important rules still depend on later regulations. Most provisions start on dates set by Scottish Ministers; the Act’s final provisions started the day after Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • People with a mental illness and debts: A moratorium must be created, but the Act itself does not say who qualifies, which debts are covered or how long it lasts. Those details are for regulations.
  • People in sequestration or considering a protected trust deed: Recall may require payment of interest, debts and trustee costs. Trustees must provide advice materials and give debtors adequate time to consider them before a trust deed is granted. Ministers will determine the required information document and can issue guidance.
  • Debtors who do not co-operate in long-running sequestration: After five years, a trustee may apply for AiB to take over if the statutory tests are met. AiB must consider representations, and decisions can be reviewed and appealed. The Act also changes when some discharge steps may happen.
  • Creditors, employers and people holding a debtor’s funds: The Act changes how some documents can be served and what information employers must provide. In specified cases, a sheriff may order a person who fails without reasonable excuse to provide required information to do so and pay the creditor the lesser of the debt due or £500.
  • People whose property or funds may be attached: Ministers must consult on possible limits and a process to seek release of attached property or funds, then report to Parliament. The Act gives Ministers power to make such rules later; it does not itself set those limits or create that application process.
  • Businesses and taxpayers: Money attachment may be carried out at business premises while they are open, without prior sheriff approval. The Act also changes procedures for attaching earnings and other property; it does not directly change tax rates or create a general debt-relief benefit.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The Act assigns functions to Scottish Ministers, AiB, trustees, employers and courts, but provides no cost or staffing estimates.
  • It creates no stated appropriation, tax change or general fee. Later regulations may set fees for appeals about orders to release attached property or funds.

What is unclear#

  • The parent Acts are not supplied, so the existing law could not be checked against these amendments. The available text does not establish how much of each amended or replaced rule is new.
  • The mental health moratorium’s eligibility, covered debts, duration, decision process and effect on creditors depend on regulations not included here.
  • Ministers must consult on attachment protections, but the Act does not require them to introduce particular exemptions or a release process.
  • The Act gives no start dates for most provisions. Those dates are to be set by regulations.
  • The information and form required for protected trust deeds, and what counts as “adequate time” to consider the material, are not fully set out in the Act.

Case for#

  • A moratorium could give eligible people with a mental illness a pause from debt recovery, while regulations can set the detailed limits and process.
  • Requiring trustees to provide advice materials and allow time to consider them may help debtors understand the consequences of a protected trust deed before agreeing to one.
  • The new process for taking over some cases after five years could allow sequestration work to continue where a debtor’s non-co-operation prevents the trustee from doing the job.
  • The Act requires consultation and a report on possible protections for attached funds and property before the first regulations on that topic.

Case against#

  • Key protections for people with mental illness and for attached funds are not defined in the Act; their practical reach depends on future regulations.
  • Giving AiB power to take over a sequestration after non-co-operation could affect a debtor’s case for a long time. The tests and review and appeal rights provide safeguards, but how the process will work in practice is not clear here.
  • Allowing money attachment at open business premises without prior sheriff approval may make enforcement more direct, while the Act does not set out additional protections specific to that change.
  • New duties and processes may require time and money from public bodies, trustees, employers and creditors, but the available material gives no estimates.