Summary#
The Visitor Levy (Scotland) Bill creates the Visitor Levy (Scotland) Act 2024; it does not amend another Act. It gives local authorities the power, but not a duty, to introduce a levy on some overnight accommodation. Its stated goal is to fund facilities and services substantially for, or used by, visitors.
- A local authority may introduce a scheme for all or part of its area, alone or jointly with another authority. Before doing so, it must consult and publish the proposal, its objectives and an impact assessment. The scheme generally cannot start until at least 18 months after the authority publishes its decision to proceed.
- The levy is a percentage of the accommodation portion of a booking. The Scottish Ministers may set a maximum rate; a local authority may set different rates for different purposes or areas, but not different rates for different types of accommodation. An authority may also set a maximum number of chargeable nights, after consultation.
- The person legally liable to pay the levy to the authority is the accommodation provider who occupies the premises. That person may arrange for someone else to collect an equivalent amount from visitors, but remains responsible for the legal duties.
- A scheme must provide for the levy not to be payable or to be reimbursed when the visitor or another person using the accommodation receives one of the disability benefits listed in the Act. The scheme must also say whether accommodation with annual turnover below the VAT threshold is exempt.
- Authorities must keep scheme money in a separate account and use net proceeds for the scheme’s objectives or, if those do not need the money, for visitor-related facilities and services. They must report yearly and review each scheme at least every three years.
- The Act provides information-gathering and inspection powers, penalties for failures such as not filing returns or paying, interest on unpaid amounts, and routes for reviews and appeals. Most provisions start on a date set by Scottish Ministers in regulations; no start date is given in the supplied material.
What it means for you#
- Visitors: You may be charged a levy when staying in covered accommodation in an area that adopts a scheme. The Act makes the accommodation provider, not the visitor, legally liable to pay the authority. The Act excludes a person’s only or usual home, certain Gypsy and Traveller sites, and vehicles or vessels making journeys with overnight stops.
- Accommodation providers: If you provide covered accommodation and occupy the premises, you must make returns, pay the levy and keep records. You may arrange for a third party to collect payments or handle returns, but that does not remove your duties. Authorities may require records and inspect business premises under the Act’s conditions.
- Local authorities: You may choose whether to introduce a scheme. If you do, you must follow consultation, publication, accounting, spending, reporting and review requirements, and establish and maintain a visitor levy forum.
- Communities, tourism businesses and tourist organisations: Authorities must consult relevant representatives when proposing a scheme and when deciding how to use net proceeds. The forum advises and discusses scheme matters; the Act does not give it decision-making power.
- People with listed disability benefits: A scheme must provide that the levy is not payable or is reimbursed in the specified cases. The scheme must set out how eligibility is shown.
Money#
No publicly available information on the cost of setting up or running schemes is in the supplied material.
- The levy rate is set by each authority, subject to any maximum rate set by Scottish Ministers.
- Authorities may deduct scheme operating expenses from receipts. They must use the net proceeds for the purposes set out in the Act.
- Providers must keep records and make returns; the material gives no estimate of those compliance costs.
- The Act permits penalties and interest for non-compliance, but does not set the penalty amounts in the text provided.
What is unclear#
- When the levy provisions will start: the Act leaves commencement to regulations, and no date is supplied.
- Which authorities will introduce schemes, their rates, scheme areas, objectives, exemptions or maximum nights.
- Whether Scottish Ministers will set a maximum levy rate, and what that rate would be.
- The detailed rules for returns, enforcement assessments, reviews and appeals depend in part on regulations. The Act does not give the full process or all deadlines.
- The Act does not explain how authorities will decide what counts as the accommodation portion in every case, or how visitor charges will be shown on bills; Ministers may make billing rules.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that it lets local authorities raise money from overnight stays to support services and facilities used by visitors, while leaving each authority to decide whether a scheme fits its area.
- Requiring consultation, impact assessments, public reporting and regular reviews could give communities and businesses a role and make authorities explain how the levy is used.
- The percentage is charged on the accommodation portion, not on listed items such as meals, drinks, parking, laundry, entertainment or transport.
Case against#
- One concern is that providers must handle returns, records and payments, and may face enforcement action or penalties. The Act does not estimate these costs.
- Different local schemes and rates could make the charge and compliance requirements vary by area. The Act does not set a national rate or require every authority to adopt the levy.
- The Act gives authorities investigation and inspection powers, while leaving penalty amounts and important process details to later rules or decisions. The supplied text does not show how all those details will work.
- It is unclear how authorities will measure whether schemes meet their objectives, or how they will balance visitor-related spending against other local needs.