Agriculture and Rural Communities (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Agriculture and Rural Communities (Scotland) Bill became the Agriculture and Rural Communities (Scotland) Act 2024. It creates a framework for Scottish Ministers to support agriculture and rural communities, and amends existing laws, including the Agriculture (Retained EU Law and Data) (Scotland) Act 2020 and the Animal Health Act 1981. Its stated goal is to support sustainable and regenerative agriculture, food production, animal health and welfare, nature recovery, climate action and thriving rural communities; these are goals, not guaranteed results.

  • Ministers must publish a five-year rural support plan, consult specified groups and public bodies when preparing or amending it, and report on support and progress.
  • Ministers may provide support for a wide range of listed purposes, including farming, food, forestry, rural businesses, training, nature and animal welfare. Support may be grants, loans or guarantees, and may go to third-party schemes.
  • Ministers may set eligibility rules and conditions, cap or reduce support, and refuse or recover it when they consider that giving it is not in the public interest. Many details depend on regulations.
  • The Act provides for possible continuing professional development (CPD) requirements for named groups, but regulations would have to set those requirements. It also requires a guidance code on sustainable and regenerative agriculture.
  • The Act changes ministers’ powers over some retained EU agricultural legislation. The supplied materials do not include the 2020 Act’s full text, so the precise difference from all existing powers cannot be verified.

What it means for you#

  • Farmers, crofters, land managers and rural businesses: You may be eligible for support, but the Act does not itself give you a payment or set a complete application process. Future rules can set eligibility, conditions and payment amounts. Ministers can also impose repayment conditions.
  • People working in agriculture and related advice or services: Ministers may make regulations requiring CPD (continuing professional development, such as training). Those regulations could set activities, fees, exemptions and enforcement. The Act does not itself impose a specific training requirement.
  • Rural communities and support organisations: Ministers may fund third-party schemes and support rural services, infrastructure and community benefits. The Act does not guarantee funding to any particular place or organisation.
  • Taxpayers: The Act authorises possible support and future regulations, but the supplied material does not set a total budget or guarantee that support will be spent.
  • General public: Ministers must publish a food-security statement at least once every three years. The Act does not itself change food prices or guarantee food security.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The Act permits support through grants, loans, guarantees and other forms, but does not specify a budget or total spending.
  • The rural support plan must indicate expected total support and how it is divided among schemes. This is a planning requirement, not an appropriation of a fixed sum.
  • Future rules may allow fees for changes to payment-entitlement registers and in connection with CPD. The Act does not set those fees.
  • No estimate is supplied for administration, staffing, enforcement or the cost of any future support or training schemes.

What is unclear#

  • Which support schemes will operate, who will qualify, how much they will pay, and when they will start.
  • How Ministers will apply the power to refuse or recover support in the public interest, including the review or appeal process. Regulations may set these details.
  • Whether, and for whom, CPD will be required; what it will cost; and how exemptions and appeals will work.
  • What the sustainable and regenerative agriculture code will recommend. The code is guidance; the Act does not itself make its recommendations binding.
  • How the changed powers over CAP (Common Agricultural Policy) legislation compare with all powers already in force. The supplied material does not include the full 2020 Act.
  • The Act’s provisions generally start on dates set by Ministers. The materials do not give those dates.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give Scotland a continuing way to support farming and rural areas, rather than relying on a single type of payment.
  • A five-year plan, consultation and published reports could make support priorities and results more visible.
  • Ministers can tailor support to different activities, land types and areas, and can fund third-party schemes.
  • Temporary support can be made available when severe market disruption harms, or is likely to harm, Scottish agricultural producers.
  • Monitoring and evaluation are required for each support scheme, and for CPD schemes.

Case against#

  • The Act gives Ministers wide discretion over support, eligibility, conditions and many details that will be decided later. Its broad purposes do not guarantee who will receive help or what outcomes will follow.
  • The public-interest power can allow support to be refused or recovered. The Act leaves key safeguards and appeal details to future regulations.
  • The rural plan and reports can describe expected support and assess results, but they do not themselves require Ministers to meet specific outcome targets.
  • Future CPD rules could bring fees and requirements for farmers, workers or advisers; the Act does not yet show their likely burden.
  • The Act allows extensive changes to some CAP-related legislation, but the supplied materials do not show the full existing-law position needed to judge the scope of those changes.