Aggregates Tax and Devolved Taxes Administration (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Aggregates Tax and Devolved Taxes Administration (Scotland) Bill became the Aggregates Tax and Devolved Taxes Administration (Scotland) Act 2024. It creates a Scottish tax on the commercial exploitation of aggregate and amends the Revenue Scotland and Tax Powers Act 2014 and rules for other devolved taxes. Its stated goal is to establish the Scottish aggregates tax and make further provision about devolved-tax administration.

  • Revenue Scotland must collect and manage the new tax. It applies when taxable aggregate—such as rock, gravel or sand—is commercially exploited in Scotland in the course of a business.
  • The tax rate and rules for measuring weight are left to regulations. The Act sets exemptions, including for previously taxed aggregate, aggregate previously used for construction, and certain excavation spoil and dredged material.
  • People responsible for commercial exploitation must register, and the Act provides for returns, payments, penalties, reviews and appeals. In some cases, more than one person can be liable, and their liability is joint and several (each can be pursued for the full amount).
  • Revenue Scotland may require security for tax it considers may become due. It may also publish information from the tax register, including registered persons’ names and site details.
  • The Act changes administration of other devolved taxes, including allowing regulations about Revenue Scotland’s use of automation and communications, and allowing it to set off some repayments against debts.

What it means for you#

  • Aggregate businesses and site operators: If you are responsible for taxable commercial exploitation, you must notify Revenue Scotland when you first intend to carry out taxable activities or begin them, whichever comes first. You must register and account for tax under rules to be set in regulations. The Act does not itself set the tax rate or full return schedule.
  • Businesses in the supply chain: Liability depends on how the aggregate is exploited. A supplier, site operator, owner, occupier or person using aggregate for construction may be liable in specified cases. In some supply chains, a person can be liable for the full tax unless they acquired the aggregate from someone registered.
  • Companies: Eligible companies may apply to be treated as a group for the tax. The representative member is responsible for the group’s tax, and group members are jointly and severally liable.
  • Businesses with a non-UK-resident taxpayer: Ministers may make regulations requiring the taxpayer to appoint a UK-resident tax representative. If required, that representative would have duties and could be personally liable in specified circumstances.
  • Taxpayers generally: The Act does not itself require Revenue Scotland to make tax decisions using automation; it lets ministers make regulations about that use. It also allows Revenue Scotland to set off certain credits or repayments against amounts owed, with limits where insolvency procedures apply.
  • Other devolved-tax taxpayers: A repayment claim may be withheld to the extent the claimant has not paid another amount due to Revenue Scotland. The Act also makes a Land and Buildings Transaction Tax amendment retrospective to 1 April 2015.
  • General public: The Act does not directly create a household benefit or change personal income tax.

Money#

No cost estimate or tax-rate figure is provided in the available material.

  • The Act creates a tax, but its rate must be set by regulations. It does not state how much revenue the tax is expected to raise.
  • The Act requires Revenue Scotland to keep a register and gives it powers to require security. It does not state the staffing or administrative cost.
  • Tax costs may be passed from a supplier to a buyer when the tax changes, unless their agreement provides otherwise.

What is unclear#

  • The tax rate, weight-measurement rules, accounting periods, return deadlines and possible tax credits depend on regulations or later rules.
  • The Act does not specify a start date for most provisions. Ministers must bring them into force by regulations, and the material does not say when that will happen.
  • The Act provides detailed tax definitions, but some practical rules—such as how weight is measured and which cases may receive credits—are left to later regulations.
  • The supplied material does not include the full Revenue Scotland and Tax Powers Act 2014. I could not verify all changes against the current text of that Act.
  • The Act refers to aggregate previously charged to the UK aggregates levy, but the supplied material does not explain the full interaction between the new Scottish tax and other current tax rules.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give Scotland its own tax on commercial exploitation of aggregate, with Revenue Scotland responsible for collection and management.
  • The Act exempts several kinds of aggregate, including material already taxed or previously used for construction. This could help avoid taxing some material again.
  • A register, return duties, penalties and review and appeal rights provide a structure for administering the tax and challenging decisions.
  • Group treatment may let eligible companies handle tax through one representative member, rather than each company accounting separately.

Case against#

  • The Act leaves the tax rate and many important operating rules to future regulations, so the full tax burden and compliance demands cannot be judged from the Act alone.
  • Joint and several liability can expose more than one business in a group or supply chain to the full amount owed.
  • Revenue Scotland may publish detailed site information, including addresses, boundaries and the type of material produced. The Act does not specify how much of that information it will publish.
  • The Act allows regulations about automated tax administration but does not itself set safeguards, review steps or limits for automated decisions.