Summary#
The Good Food Nation (Scotland) Bill became the Good Food Nation (Scotland) Act 2022. It requires Scottish Ministers and certain public authorities to make and report on food plans; its stated purpose is to set out the plans’ effect on their decisions.
- Ministers must publish a national plan with food-related outcomes, ways to measure progress, and policies intended to achieve those outcomes. They must consult on a draft and lay a proposed plan before Parliament for 60 days before finalising it.
- Health boards, local authorities and other public authorities specified by Ministers must publish their own plans. Those plans must take account of the national plan.
- Ministers and relevant authorities must have regard to their plans when carrying out functions specified in regulations. The Act does not require them to achieve every planned outcome.
- Ministers and relevant authorities must report on progress every two years and review their plans every five years. Ministers’ reports must explain whether policies remain sufficient for outcomes not being achieved, and what action they intend to take if they consider the policies insufficient.
- The Act establishes the Scottish Food Commission, an independent public body. It must monitor plans and progress and may advise, assist, research and make public recommendations. It cannot direct Ministers or authorities to adopt its recommendations under the powers described here.
What it means for you#
- People generally: The Act does not directly create an individual right to food, a food benefit, a new food service, or a change to food prices or taxes. It requires government and specified public bodies to plan and report.
- Children and young people, and people who need communication support: Ministers and relevant authorities must have regard to communicating inclusively and in ways effective at engaging children and young people when consulting on plans. They must also have regard to inclusive communication when publishing documents.
- Local authorities and health boards: They must make plans, consult on drafts, report every two years, and review plans every five years. They must have regard to their plans when carrying out functions specified by Ministers.
- Other public authorities: They must make plans only if Ministers specify them in regulations. Which authorities and functions will be covered depends on those regulations.
- Food businesses and public bodies: Plans must consider food-system and supply-chain roles, nutrition, human rights, climate, biodiversity, animal welfare, fair work and resilient local economies. The Act does not itself require a particular business practice or food outcome.
- Scottish Ministers: They must make and report on the national plan, and may fund the Commission. They may also set conditions on that funding, including repayment conditions.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the supplied material.
- Ministers may provide the Commission with grants, loans, guarantees or indemnities; the Act sets no amount.
- The Commission may appoint staff, but the Act does not require a particular staffing level. Ministers approve staff terms and conditions.
- Ministers may pay Commission members’ remuneration, allowances and pensions. No amount is specified.
- The cost of preparing plans, consultations, reports and reviews is not estimated.
What is unclear#
- The Act leaves the functions that must have regard to the plans to be specified in regulations. The supplied material does not identify them.
- Other public authorities become relevant authorities only if specified by regulations. The supplied material does not name any.
- The Act sets duties to make plans and have regard to them, but does not prescribe specific outcomes or require plans to achieve them.
- The supplied material does not give the commencement date for most provisions; the Act leaves this to regulations.
- The food-related issue definition refers to definitions in the Food (Scotland) Act 2015, which was not supplied, so those definitions could not be checked here.
- No publicly available information on expected total costs, staffing numbers, or funding for the Commission is included in the supplied material.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the Act is that plans, measures and regular reports can make government’s food aims clearer and let the public track progress.
- Requiring plans to consider health, poverty, the environment, animal welfare and the food economy could help public bodies consider how food decisions affect more than one policy area.
- The Commission can conduct or support research and publish recommendations, which could provide independent scrutiny and advice.
Case against#
- The Act requires bodies to have regard to plans for specified functions; it does not require them to meet the plans’ outcomes. The practical effect may therefore depend heavily on the plans and the functions later specified.
- The Commission can recommend action, but the Act does not give it power to require Ministers or public authorities to follow its advice.
- The Act permits public spending and Commission staffing but provides no cost estimates in the supplied material.
- It is unclear which additional public authorities and government functions will be covered, so the eventual scope of the duties is not set by the Act alone.