Land Reform (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The bill is now the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2025. It amends existing Scottish laws on land reform and agricultural tenancies, and adds a new legal regime for small landholdings. Its stated goals include changing how large landholdings are managed and transferred, and changing some rules for tenants.

  • Scottish Ministers must make regulations requiring owners of some holdings over 1,000 hectares to meet community-engagement obligations. The rules must include a public land management plan, but they may apply to less than all eligible land.
  • For qualifying large holdings, a transfer can be paused while communities have time to register an interest. Ministers can also require some transfers to be split into lots (separate parcels), but only if they find that doing so is in the public interest under the Act’s test.
  • The Act creates a Land and Communities Commissioner office within the existing Scottish Land Commission, not a separate independent body. The Commissioner can investigate and fine owners for breaches of land-management obligations; the maximum fine is £40,000.
  • The Act requires Ministers to publish model leases for environmental uses and for huts on public land. It does not require anyone to offer or take up those leases.
  • It changes rules for agricultural tenancies, including compensation when landlords resume land, tenant improvements, diversification and rent reviews. It also sets out a new regime for small landholdings, generally capped at 20 hectares, with exceptions for some existing holdings.
  • Most provisions start on dates set by Scottish Ministers. Some provisions start the day after Royal Assent; the available material does not give the start dates for most of the rest.

What it means for you#

  • Owners of large holdings: Where regulations apply, you must provide a public land management plan, engage with communities and tenants on its development and significant changes, and review it at least every five years. Regulations will set the details. The Act also creates transfer restrictions and a lotting process for qualifying land.
  • Communities: A qualifying community body can ask an owner to consider leasing land, or, in crofting areas, ask for an application to have land constituted as a croft. The owner must consider a reasonable request; the Act does not require the owner to agree. Communities may also get time to register an interest before a large holding is transferred, but this is not a guarantee they can buy it.
  • Agricultural tenants: The Act changes some rights and procedures for assigning or succeeding to a tenancy, making improvements, diversifying land use, and seeking compensation. For some resumptions, a tenant is entitled to an additional payment based on half the difference between the land’s value with vacant possession and its value with the tenant still in occupation.
  • Small landholders and their landlords: The Act sets rules for rent, diversification, compensation, succession, removal and a right to buy in specified transfer situations. Small landholders may generally register an interest in buying their holding; that is not the same as an unconditional right to buy at any time.
  • People seeking huts or environmental leases on public land: Ministers must publish model leases, but the Act does not require a public landowner to offer a lease or approve a particular use.
  • General public: Most of the Act’s rules will depend on regulations and commencement dates. The material does not establish when all of them will take effect.

Money#

No publicly available information on the Act’s total public cost.

  • The Act gives the Commissioner investigation and enforcement functions, but provides no staffing or cost estimate.
  • Ministers must compensate owners or eligible creditors for specified losses or expenses linked to lotting restrictions. Ministers may also offer to buy lots in certain cases after a review.
  • Future regulations may require reasonable fees for some functions. Fines are paid into the Scottish Consolidated Fund.
  • The Act creates compensation duties between landlords and tenants, but the available material does not estimate how much will be paid.

What is unclear#

  • The regulations that will set the land-management duties, including which eligible holdings those duties will cover, are not included.
  • The Act leaves details of several processes to regulations, including fees, some transfer exemptions and procedures for tenant compensation claims.
  • The Act allows Ministers to decide that land should be transferred in lots under a public-interest test, but the full practical process will depend on guidance and regulations.
  • The Act does not set out all commencement dates. Most provisions begin only when Ministers appoint a start date.
  • The parent Acts being amended were not supplied. I could not verify the current law against those Acts or establish how much of the amended wording is new rather than retained or revised existing law.

Case for#

  • The land-management plans and engagement duties appear intended to give communities and tenants more information about large holdings and a role in discussing significant plans.
  • The transfer process gives communities time to register an interest before some large holdings are sold, while the Act sets a higher support and public-interest test for the special invited application process.
  • Lotting may help diversify ownership where Ministers find that separate ownership is more likely to support a sustainable nearby community than transfer to one buyer.
  • Updated tenancy rules may give agricultural tenants clearer routes for diversification, compensation and succession.

Case against#

  • Transfer pauses and lotting decisions can restrict an owner’s ability to transfer land as a single holding. The Act provides compensation for specified losses, but does not estimate the public cost.
  • Many key duties depend on future regulations. Until those rules are made, owners and communities may not know exactly what plans, engagement or fees will be required.
  • The Act allows land-management duties to cover less than all qualifying land, and does not itself set the final coverage.
  • The owner must consider certain community requests but does not have to grant them. The practical effect for communities will therefore depend on the regulations and how the duties are enforced.