Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Bill would create a new Scottish law; it does not amend a named existing Act. It would let eligible terminally ill adults request help to end their own lives, subject to checks and safeguards. Its stated goal is to provide that assistance lawfully. The bill has fallen and is not law; its short-title provision says it would be called the Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Act 2024.

  • Eligibility would be limited to adults who can reasonably be expected to die within six months, have lived in Scotland for at least 12 months, are registered with a Scottish medical practice, and have capacity to make the request. Disability or mental disorder alone would not make someone terminally ill.
  • A coordinating doctor and an independent doctor would have to assess the person in person, including whether the request is voluntary and whether the person has been offered or provided with relevant social care and palliative care. The person must make two declarations; normally, at least 14 days must pass between them.
  • A doctor or authorised health professional could provide an approved substance for the adult to use. The adult—not a professional—must decide to use it and take the final act. A professional must remain with them and monitor them after use.
  • The Scottish Ministers would have to ensure access to independent advocacy for people who request it, and make rules for the service. They must also make rules about assistance outside the NHS and assess its likely effect on palliative and end-of-life care.
  • The bill would protect assistance provided under its rules from criminal and civil liability, and require reporting, reviews and records. It would also require rules creating offences for advertising an assisted-dying service.

What it means for you#

  • Adults seeking assistance: The bill would create a route to request it, but meeting the eligibility rules would not itself guarantee approval. You could cancel either declaration at any time. You could request a palliative care support plan and, if you request an advocate, would have a right of access to independent advocacy.
  • Doctors and other health professionals: A doctor asked to coordinate care who is unwilling or unable to do so must direct the person to a doctor who may be willing, or to information about the process. No doctor would have a duty to raise assisted dying. A nurse providing the substance must be accompanied by a doctor or another authorised health professional who is a doctor.
  • NHS and other care providers: The bill requires further rules on provision outside the NHS, including settings where assistance must not be provided. It does not itself set out the full service arrangements or guarantee that the NHS will provide the service.
  • People under 18: A health professional must not raise assisted dying with someone under 18 unless that person raised it first. It must not be part of a person under 18’s future care plan.
  • People who pressure someone: Coercing or pressuring an eligible adult to make a declaration or use the substance would be an offence. The bill leaves the offence and penalties for advertising to later regulations.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill would require the Scottish Ministers to ensure independent advocacy is available when needed, and to fund reporting, reviews and other assigned duties. It gives no cost estimate or staffing figure.
  • The bill does not set out an appropriation, fee or payment to people who use the process. Any cost of providing assistance and related services is not estimated in the supplied material.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves important operating details to future regulations and guidance, including approved substances and devices, staff training, rules for non-NHS settings, and advocacy standards.
  • It does not specify how the service would be arranged in practice, how many staff it would need, or how quickly a person would move through the steps.
  • The bill requires relevant care to have been offered or provided, but does not define what counts as “appropriate” care. The availability and quality of palliative and social care may affect how this requirement works.
  • The bill requires information to be collected and reviewed, but the detailed rules for information-sharing and reporting would come later.
  • The bill’s provisions could not start until UK Parliament legislation made the specified provision on professional training and employment protections. The supplied material does not say when that would happen.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that an eligible adult who has capacity could make a voluntary choice about the timing and manner of their death.
  • The two-doctor assessments, in-person checks, reflection period and ability to cancel are intended to test that the choice is informed and voluntary.
  • Required discussions about treatment and palliative options, along with access to advocacy on request, could help people understand alternatives and express their wishes.
  • Recording and reviewing cases could help identify safety concerns or unequal effects.

Case against#

  • One concern is that indirect pressures—such as feeling like a burden or facing financial pressure—may be difficult to identify or separate from a person’s own choice, even with assessments and advocacy.
  • The bill does not define what counts as “appropriate” social care or palliative care. If support is unavailable, it may be unclear how the requirement would work in practice.
  • Many safeguards and service rules depend on later regulations and guidance. Until those are made, the practical process and protections would remain uncertain.
  • The bill requires later reviews of the effects on palliative care, but that does not establish in advance how the assisted-dying service would affect care staff, providers or funding.