Summary#
The Criminal Justice Modernisation and Abusive Domestic Behaviour Reviews (Scotland) Act 2025 amends criminal procedure laws and creates a system for reviewing certain deaths linked to abusive domestic behaviour. Its stated goal is to help lessons be learned from those deaths. Some provisions have a set start point, while others require a start date to be set by Scottish Ministers.
- Court procedure: The Act allows electronic signatures and certain electronic ways of sending court documents. It also lets courts use digital images of physical evidence in place of the item itself, unless the court decides this would make proceedings unfair.
- Virtual attendance: Courts can allow some people to attend criminal hearings remotely, subject to fairness and justice safeguards. In proceedings where the only party is a public official, physical attendance is not required unless the court orders it. Other criminal proceedings need a determination by the Lord Justice General before physical-attendance rules can be set aside.
- Other criminal procedure changes: The Act raises the fixed-penalty limit to £500, allows Ministers to set a higher limit by regulations, and lets custody cases be called in courts elsewhere in Scotland in specified circumstances. It also allows prosecutors to apply to add a charge to an indictment after it has been served, subject to conditions and court oversight.
- Reviews of deaths: A review oversight committee decides whether to hold a review and must establish a case review panel when a review is to go ahead. The reviews cover specified deaths linked to abusive behaviour; in some cases, with the Lord Advocate’s consent, a review can also examine support and welfare decisions affecting children, young people or adults at risk after a death.
- Public bodies and reporting: Named public bodies must cooperate with reviews and provide information in some circumstances. Panels must prepare reports. The committee may publish reports only with the Lord Advocate’s consent, but must publish information about recommendations.
What it means for you#
- Accused people and witnesses: You may be directed to attend a hearing electronically rather than in person, but a court can require physical attendance. If you are accused, certain digital images may be treated as the physical evidence; you can ask the court not to do so if using the image would prejudice a fair trial. The Act also sets a seven-day period to dispute displayed time, date or place details in certain police body-worn video recordings, after disclosure and written notice.
- People charged with an offence: A prosecutor may seek to add a charge after an indictment is served only if the prosecutor did not know, and could not reasonably have known, of the relevant act or omission earlier, and applies as soon as reasonably practicable. If the change could prejudice the defence, the court must provide a fair remedy, such as an adjournment.
- Police, prosecutors and courts: They may use the Act’s new document, evidence and court-attendance rules. Prosecutors must publish guidance on when they use images of physical evidence. A two-year review of the virtual-attendance provisions is required.
- People affected by a potentially reviewable death and their families: A review is not automatic. The committee must assess whether a death qualifies and whether a review should be held. A review may examine post-death support and welfare decisions for certain children, young people or adults at risk, but only with the Lord Advocate’s consent.
- Public authorities and other information holders: Named public authorities must cooperate with reviews, subject to limits on information they can refuse to provide in court. Ministers and review chairs can also require information from other people when they reasonably consider it necessary for their functions.
- General public: The Act does not create a new criminal offence or a general right to take part in a review. It does not require every review report to be published, and published reports must take steps to protect people’s identities.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The Act allows Ministers to pay expenses for review participants and to pay review office-holders’ remuneration, allowances and expenses. It does not give an estimate or set out how much will be spent.
- The materials do not estimate costs for staffing the committee and panels, handling information requests, or making the required reports.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the current versions of the Acts being amended. I could not verify which criminal procedure rules are genuinely new, rather than changes or re-enactments of existing rules.
- Several review provisions require commencement regulations. The supplied material does not give their start dates.
- The Act does not set out a general timeline for deciding whether to hold a review or completing one, or an appeal process against a decision not to hold one.
- Some terms defining which deaths qualify rely on the meaning of abusive behaviour in another Act. The Act also lets Ministers change review coverage by regulations.
- The review system can share reports only within legal limits, and public report publication needs the Lord Advocate’s consent. The materials do not explain how often consent will be given.
- No publicly available information in the supplied materials sets out the expected number of reviews or their staffing and operating costs.
Case for#
- The review system appears intended to identify lessons from deaths linked to abusive domestic behaviour, including missed opportunities to safeguard people or support victims.
- A committee and separate case panels provide a defined structure for deciding whether to review a death and examining the case.
- Requiring named public authorities to cooperate and provide information could help panels examine what happened across services.
- Allowing electronic documents and images, and remote attendance where fair, could make some court processes less dependent on paper or physical attendance.
Case against#
- A review is not guaranteed for every death that could qualify: the committee weighs the likelihood of finding useful lessons and other listed factors, and Ministers have a power to direct a review in some cases.
- The Act gives Ministers powers to change which circumstances qualify for reviews, while leaving important details—including decision and completion timelines—unset.
- Review reports may not be published without the Lord Advocate’s consent. That may limit what the public can learn from individual cases, although the committee must publish information about recommendations.
- The Act creates duties and powers for public bodies and permits payments for review work, but the available material does not quantify the workload or cost.