Building Safety Levy (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Building Safety Levy (Scotland) Bill, shown as having reached Royal Assent, creates a new tax and amends the Building (Scotland) Act 2003 and the Revenue Scotland and Tax Powers Act 2014. Its stated goal is to raise money for work to improve building safety; that goal is not a guarantee of a particular result.

  • Revenue Scotland must collect and manage the levy. The tax applies to certain building-control events when construction or conversion creates a new residential unit.
  • The owner of a unit at the relevant building-control step is liable. If there is more than one owner, they are jointly and severally liable (each can be held responsible for the full amount).
  • A taxpayer gets an allowance of 29 building-control events per financial year. Regulations must also provide at least 50% relief for units created on brownfield land.
  • Some units are exempt, including qualifying social housing, certain publicly funded affordable housing, qualifying pre-existing residences and units on islands. The Act also excludes listed types of accommodation, such as hotels and certain residential institutions.
  • Levy proceeds must be used by Scottish Ministers for specified building-safety work in buildings with an external wall cladding system, including remediation, mitigation, prevention, and related surveys or assessments.

What it means for you#

  • Residential property developers and owners: The levy is calculated by multiplying the applicable rate by the unit’s measured floor area. Rates, which Ministers must set in regulations, may differ by area, land type or other factors. The charge applies only after reliefs and the allowance are taken into account.
  • Owners liable to register: You must notify Revenue Scotland when you become liable to register. That is generally when you own a unit at the submission of a completion certificate or, if earlier, an application for permission for temporary occupation. Registration is required where a later building-control event would be taxable, or would be taxable but for a relief.
  • People buying or living in housing: The Act does not directly change housing rights, rents or the rules for buying a home. It does not say whether or how the levy would affect development costs or property prices.
  • Scottish Ministers and Revenue Scotland: Ministers must make regulations setting the levy rate and providing the required brownfield relief. They may set other reliefs and rules. Revenue Scotland keeps the register and administers the tax.
  • The public: The Act requires Ministers to report on its operation at intervals they choose, no more than three years apart, and publish each report.

Money#

No publicly available information on expected revenue, levy rates, administration costs or the amount of building-safety work the levy would fund.

  • The rate will be set later by regulations and linked to floor area. The Act does not specify a rate.
  • The tax is payable by the owner identified in the Act, not directly by homebuyers or tenants.
  • Levy proceeds must be used for the specified building-safety purposes. The Act gives no estimate of those proceeds or costs.
  • The levy provisions start on a date Ministers appoint; the text gives no start date. The Act is set to expire 15 years after its expiry provision comes into force, unless Ministers extend it.

What is unclear#

  • What the rates will be, how floor area will be measured, and when the levy will begin.
  • Which additional reliefs Ministers will create, if any, and how eligibility will work. The Act requires brownfield relief but leaves its details to regulations.
  • How Ministers will decide which buildings or works receive funding, and how much each will receive.
  • How “external wall cladding system” will be applied; the supplied text does not define it.
  • The supplied material does not include the parent Acts, so it is not possible to verify how the tax-administration and building-control provisions compare with current law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the levy is that it creates a dedicated source of money for safety work, including remediation and prevention in buildings with external wall cladding systems.
  • Charging at a building-control step links the tax to construction or conversion that creates residential units.
  • The allowance, exemptions and mandatory brownfield relief reduce or remove charges for specified cases.
  • Regular public reports could show how proceeds were used and what safety work they helped fund.

Case against#

  • The tax rate, start date and several key rules are left for later regulations, so owners cannot tell from the Act what they would owe.
  • Owners may face a tax on new residential units even though the Act does not say whether the cost will affect development, prices or rents.
  • The Act requires the proceeds to serve a broad set of safety purposes but does not set out how funding will be allocated between buildings or projects.
  • Ministers can change which types of buildings are included or exempt through regulations, and the Act does not set a maximum rate.