Victims exempt from clemency notices

Summary#

HB 1300, “An Act to except victims of human trafficking or domestic abuse from certain clemency notice requirements,” adds a section to South Dakota’s existing Chapter 24-14. It exempts qualifying clemency applicants from the provisions of § 24-14-4; the bill’s stated goal is to protect applicants whose safety may be at risk if personal information is published in a newspaper.

  • An applicant must submit an affidavit saying they are a victim of human trafficking, domestic abuse, or a similar crime in another state, and that publication of personal information in a newspaper would put their safety at risk.
  • The applicant must also submit affidavits from two eligible professionals who have worked with them and believe they are a victim and have a good-faith belief their safety is at risk.
  • The two professionals may be from the same profession, but not from the same agency. Eligible professionals include law enforcement officers, prosecutors, parole agents, qualified mental health professionals, licensed health care providers, addiction counseling or prevention services practitioners, and certain social workers, crisis counselors, or advocates.
  • The exemption does not waive the applicant’s rights to notification under the state constitution or other victim-rights laws.

What it means for you#

  • Clemency applicants who are victims: If you meet the bill’s conditions and provide the required affidavits, § 24-14-4 does not apply to you.
  • Professionals providing affidavits: You must have worked with the applicant and hold the stated beliefs. You and the other professional cannot be from the same agency.
  • Other victims and the public: The bill does not change clemency eligibility or establish a new clemency process in the text provided. It also does not remove a qualifying applicant’s separate rights to victim notification.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.

  • The bill requires applicants to provide affidavits, but gives no estimate of related costs or staffing.
  • No fees, fines, or spending amount are stated.

What is unclear#

  • The text of § 24-14-4 was not supplied, so its current notice requirements—and exactly which requirements the exemption removes—could not be verified.
  • The bill does not set out how the Board of Pardons and Paroles decides whether submitted affidavits meet the requirements, or what happens if they do not.
  • It does not state when the new section takes effect.
  • The bill does not define every term it uses, including “good faith belief” and “qualified mental health professional.”

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives qualifying victims a way to seek an exception from clemency notice rules when newspaper publication of personal information could put their safety at risk.
  • Requiring the applicant and two professionals to provide affidavits may help document the claim.
  • The bill preserves other victim-notification rights rather than waiving them.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill does not explain how the Board will assess the affidavits, which could leave the decision process unclear.
  • The bill does not specify what information may still be published or how the exception will be handled in practice.
  • Because the current text of § 24-14-4 is not included, the full effect of the exemption cannot be assessed from the supplied material.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1643065

    Passed66 members voted

    Do Pass Amended

    FOR · 66

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    66For

    • Republican61
    • Democratic5

    0Against

    4 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1640166

    Passed13 members voted

    Do Pass Amended

    FOR · 13

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    13For

    • Republican12
    • Democratic1

    0Against