Local referendum petition rules rewritten

Summary#

HB 1323, titled “Modify the requirements to refer an ordinance or resolution to the voters of a political subdivision,” amends several South Dakota laws; it does not create a new agency or program. Its stated goal is to change how voters can require local decisions to go to a vote. The bill has passed the Legislature and been delivered to the Governor; the supplied material does not say whether it was signed.

  • For many county and municipal decisions, a referendum petition would need signatures from at least 5% of registered voters or 2,500 voters, whichever is fewer, and must be filed within 20 days. Some decisions would remain excluded, including decisions needed for immediate public peace, health or safety, and decisions that carry out an adopted plan or supervise programs, employees or officials.
  • A county or municipal ordinance or resolution referred to voters would not take effect until the referendum process is complete. The bill also lists types of ordinances and resolutions that take effect upon passage and publication, such as those calling for bids.
  • It sets or revises similar petition rules for decisions including annexations, special zoning areas, school-board term changes, early school-year start dates, and school sentinel programs.
  • For certain school-district and taxing-district excess tax levies, voters could file a petition with signatures from 5% of registered voters or 2,500, whichever is fewer. The bill also changes publication requirements for some tax-levy decisions.

What it means for you#

  • County and municipal voters: A 2,500-signature cap could mean fewer signatures are needed in a large county or municipality than under a 5%-only rule. The petition deadline is generally 20 days, but the filing office and voter-count method vary by decision.
  • People in areas affected by annexation or special zoning: The bill provides a petition route to refer these decisions to a vote, with a 5% or 2,500-voter limit, whichever is fewer.
  • School-district voters: The bill sets petition rules for the listed school-board decisions. For excess tax levies, a qualifying petition would lead to an election on or before October 1 of the year before the taxes are payable.
  • Property taxpayers: The bill does not itself raise taxes or change tax rates. It changes referendum and notice procedures for certain proposed levies.
  • Local governments and school districts: They would need to handle petitions and any resulting elections under the revised rules. For some tax-levy decisions, they would also have to publish additional notices.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill sets no dollar amount for election administration, additional notices, or other implementation costs.
  • If a petition leads to an election, the responsible local body would have election-related work and costs; the materials do not estimate them.
  • The bill does not itself authorize a new tax or specify new public funding.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not show whether the Governor signed the bill or when it would take effect.
  • The parent statutes and current versions were not supplied, so the full changes against current law cannot be independently verified from those statutes.
  • The bill does not define the boundaries of some exclusions, such as when a decision “executes” an adopted plan or involves supervision of a program.
  • Petition details differ across decisions, including where petitions are filed and how the number of registered voters is counted.
  • The materials do not estimate local costs or explain how overlapping referendum rules would work where more than one may apply.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that the 2,500-signature cap can make it easier for voters in larger jurisdictions to seek a referendum, while keeping a 5% requirement where that is the lower number.
  • Clearer filing deadlines, petition offices and rules for particular decisions could make the referendum process easier to follow.
  • Referendums give voters a way to challenge certain local decisions, including some proposed tax levies, before they take effect.

Case against#

  • A lower signature requirement in large jurisdictions could lead to more referendum elections, which take public staff time and money; the bill provides no cost estimate.
  • A referendum can delay a county or municipal ordinance or resolution from taking effect until the process is complete.
  • The exclusions for decisions that carry out adopted plans or supervise programs are not fully defined, leaving uncertainty about which decisions voters can refer.
  • The bill changes procedures across many types of local decisions, but the materials do not explain how local bodies should handle possible overlap among the rules.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1659477

    Passed67 members voted

    Failed to concur, no committee appointed

    FOR · 40AGAINST · 27

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    40For

    • Republican35
    • Democratic5

    27Against

    • Republican27

    3 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1640074

    Passed67 members voted

    Do Pass Amended

    FOR · 39AGAINST · 28

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    39For

    • Republican34
    • Democratic5

    28Against

    • Republican28

    3 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  3. Division No. 1638386

    Passed12 members voted

    Do Pass

    FOR · 10AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    10For

    • Republican8
    • Democratic2

    2Against

    • Republican2

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.