Summary#
HB-1, titled “An Act to amend Tennessee Code Annotated, Section 29-39-102, relative to civil damage awards,” would amend Tennessee’s civil-damages law. It would require a $1 million statutory award in a defined case involving the death of a person after an abortion-inducing drug was sent into Tennessee; the stated reason is that actual damages may be difficult to measure. The bill is introduced, not law, and its passage is uncertain.
- The award would apply if a defendant violated the referenced law by sending the drug to a patient in Tennessee by courier, delivery, or mail, and the patient or a wrongful-death beneficiary proves by a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not) that the drug caused a person’s death.
- The $1 million award would replace, not add to, compensatory damages under the referenced subsection.
- The new award would not apply to an action against a pharmacist, physician, motor carrier, freight forwarder, or air carrier.
- The bill says it does not create a new health-care-liability action, change health-care providers’ standard of care, alter the evidence burden, or expand liability under the health-care-liability law. It also says existing limits on noneconomic damages are unaffected.
- The bill would replace another subsection with wording that, except for this new subsection, the chapter does not create or enhance certain claims or damages under law in existence before July 1, 2027. The current subsection is not supplied, so the extent of that change cannot be verified.
What it means for you#
- Patients and wrongful-death beneficiaries: If the conditions above are met, a court would have to award $1 million. The bill does not provide both that award and compensatory damages under the referenced subsection.
- People or businesses accused of sending the drug: They could face this award if the required violation and causation are proved. The listed exclusions mean this subsection would not apply to an action against the named pharmacists, physicians, carriers, or freight forwarders; it does not establish that they are immune from other claims.
- Health-care providers: The bill says it does not change the standard of care or create a new health-care-liability action.
- General public: The bill does not create a public benefit program or appropriate public funds in the text provided.
Money#
No public cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- A qualifying defendant would owe a $1 million statutory award to the patient or wrongful-death beneficiary. It would replace, rather than add to, the specified compensatory damages.
- The bill gives no estimate of how many cases might qualify or of other public, business, or court costs.
What is unclear#
- The referenced laws that define “abortion-inducing drug” and prohibit the described conduct are not supplied, so their full scope cannot be verified.
- The current text of the amended damages law is not supplied. This prevents comparison of the bill’s changes with current law, including the effect of replacing subsection (m).
- The bill does not explain how the $1 million award interacts with the existing limits on noneconomic damages, which it says remain unaffected.
- The bill does not add rules for filing, investigating, or deciding these claims beyond the proof requirement and listed exclusions.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to provide a set damages amount when a drug shipment is proved to have caused a death and actual damages are difficult to measure.
- A fixed award could make the damages amount more predictable for both claimants and defendants.
- Excluding the listed health-care and shipping groups limits which defendants can face this particular award.
Case against#
- A mandatory $1 million award may not match the circumstances or actual losses in every case that meets the bill’s conditions.
- The bill does not explain how the award fits with existing noneconomic-damage limits, even though it says those limits are unchanged.
- Because the referenced prohibition and definitions are not supplied, the full range of conduct and potential defendants covered cannot be assessed from the available material.