Drug Death Claims Could Carry $1 Million Award

Summary#

SB 2 would amend Tennessee Code Annotated § 29-39-102, an existing law on civil damage awards. It would require a $1 million statutory damage award in a specified case involving an abortion-inducing drug sent into Tennessee; the bill’s stated rationale is that actual damages are difficult to measure in that situation. The bill has been introduced but is not law; if enacted, it would apply to causes of action accruing on or after July 1, 2027.

  • A court would have to award $1 million if a patient or wrongful-death beneficiary proves, by a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not), that the drug caused a person’s death and the defendant violated the referenced law by sending the drug into Tennessee to a patient by courier, delivery, or mail.
  • The award would replace, not add to, compensatory damages (money for actual loss) under the referenced section. A court could not award both.
  • The new award would not apply to an action against a pharmacist, physician, motor carrier, freight forwarder, or air carrier.
  • The bill says this rule does not create a new health care liability action, change a health care provider’s standard of care, change an evidentiary burden, or expand liability under Tennessee’s health care liability law.
  • It would amend an existing rule so the chapter generally does not create or enhance claims or damages under law in existence before July 1, 2027, except as provided by the new subsection.

What it means for you#

  • Patients and wrongful-death beneficiaries: If the stated conditions are met, you could bring an action seeking the statutory award. The bill does not set out an application process or guarantee an award without proof in court.
  • Potential defendants: A defendant who meets the bill’s conditions could face a required $1 million award. The listed pharmacists, physicians, carriers, and freight forwarders are excluded from this particular award.
  • People in Tennessee generally: The bill does not itself establish a new health service, benefit, or public program.
  • Current law: The materials do not include the amended statutes or the parent law, so it is not possible to verify what § 63-6-1103(b) currently prohibits or how the bill’s change compares with current law.

Money#

The bill provides for a $1 million civil award in qualifying cases; no public cost estimate is included.

  • The award would be paid by the defendant to the patient or wrongful-death beneficiary, not from a fund created by the bill.
  • The bill gives no estimate of how many cases might qualify or the total amount that might be awarded.
  • No funding, staffing, tax, or fee change is specified.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the referenced statutes. The meaning of “abortion-inducing drug,” the underlying violation, and the definition of a person whose death can support the claim could not be checked.
  • The bill does not explain how this award would interact with other claims or damages outside the compensatory damages it expressly replaces.
  • The bill does not provide rules for filing or deciding a claim, or specify timelines beyond applying to causes of action accruing on or after July 1, 2027.
  • The supplied material does not show how much of the amendment to subsection (m) changes existing law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that actual losses may be difficult to measure in the death-related cases it describes. A fixed award would make the amount of this particular civil remedy clear.
  • The bill limits the award to cases where the claimant proves both a statutory violation and that the drug caused a person’s death.
  • Excluding specified health professionals and transportation businesses narrows who can face this particular award.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the fixed $1 million award may not match the losses in an individual case, and the claimant cannot receive it on top of compensatory damages under the referenced section.
  • The bill does not explain how its new award would fit with other possible legal claims.
  • Without the referenced statutes, the scope of the conduct that triggers the award and the effect on existing law cannot be fully assessed.