Summary#
HB-10, the “Ending the Grocery Tax by Closing Corporate Loopholes Act,” would amend Tennessee tax laws and add a new corporate tax-reporting system called the Worldwide Combined Reporting Act. Its stated goal is to end the sales tax on food and food ingredients sold at retail and change how some large or internationally active businesses report income for state tax purposes. It has been introduced but is not law; the bill text does not include the current versions of the amended laws, so the full extent of some changes cannot be verified.
- Retail sales of food and food ingredients would generally be exempt from sales tax, except as provided in a subsection the bill does not include.
- Counties and municipalities would receive an amount “substantially equal” to what they would have received from the sales tax on those food sales. The state revenue commissioner would base the amount on reported exempt sales and other relevant information.
- Businesses in a unitary group (businesses linked through shared control and economic activity) meeting any of three tests would have to file a combined return covering group members wherever they are located. The tests include more than $1 billion in gross revenue reported in securities filings, liability for the federal corporate alternative minimum tax, or being within the scope of the OECD’s Pillar Two rules.
- Other taxpayers could elect combined reporting for at least 10 consecutive years. Those not using that method would have to apportion 50% of certain foreign-company income under federal tax law to the United States for state tax purposes.
- Group members would be jointly and severally liable for the combined group’s tax (each member could be held responsible for the full group liability). The Department of Revenue could require some additional unitary-business members to be included.
- Two alcohol-license provisions would count food sales toward a 20% sales threshold even though the food sales would no longer be taxable sales.
What it means for you#
- Shoppers: Food and food ingredients sold at retail would generally no longer be subject to Tennessee sales tax. The bill does not include the subsection that states the exception, so its scope cannot be fully checked.
- Counties and municipalities: They would receive replacement distributions tied to the sales tax revenue they would otherwise have received from food sales. The bill does not set a specific amount or calculation formula.
- Large and internationally active businesses: If a unitary business meets one of the bill’s tests, its members would have to report group income and apportionment factors (figures used to assign income to Tennessee) together, including information from members located outside the United States. Captive insurers in the unitary business must be included.
- Other businesses in unitary groups: They could choose combined reporting, but the election would bind them for at least 10 consecutive years. Businesses outside the required and elective methods would still face the bill’s 50% rule for certain foreign-company income.
- Businesses in affected groups: Members would share liability for group tax. The Department of Revenue could require additional members’ income and factors to be included in specified circumstances.
- General public: The bill does not directly change personal income tax, create a new benefit, or establish a new public service.
Money#
No cost estimate is in the available material; no publicly available information is provided.
- The bill would remove sales tax from most retail food and food-ingredient sales, but gives no estimate of lost state revenue.
- It requires replacement distributions to counties and municipalities, but gives no estimate of their cost or the method for calculating payments.
- The bill creates new filing and income-calculation requirements for affected business groups. It gives no estimate of business compliance costs or Department of Revenue staffing costs.
- The bill does not state how revenue from the new reporting method would compare with current revenue.
What is unclear#
- The current text of the amended statutes is not supplied. It is therefore unclear which provisions are new, and what the bill’s changes to several sales-tax and alcohol-license provisions would do beyond the text shown.
- The bill refers to an exception in the food-tax exemption, but does not provide that exception.
- It does not define how the Department of Revenue would calculate the replacement distributions, or how often they would be made.
- It does not specify the rules, forms, deadlines, or review and appeal process for combined returns. Some details are left to department rules.
- The bill does not explain how its reporting method would interact with other state tax rules, beyond the credits and adjustments stated in the text.
- The bill says department decisions on matters left to the commissioner’s discretion receive “substantial deference” from courts, but does not further explain how that standard would apply.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to reduce the sales-tax cost of buying food while protecting county and municipal distributions tied to those sales.
- Requiring related businesses to report income together could make it harder to shift income among parts of one business to change how much income is assigned to Tennessee.
- Including foreign members and captive insurers could give the state a fuller picture of a unitary business’s income and activity.
- Allowing other businesses to elect combined reporting offers a choice, although the choice lasts at least 10 years.
Case against#
- Removing the food sales tax could reduce state revenue, while the bill provides no estimate of that loss or of how replacement local payments would be funded.
- Worldwide reporting could require businesses to gather and calculate information across many countries and entities; the bill gives no estimate of those costs.
- The Department of Revenue would have broad power to require additional members’ information and factors in some cases, while key procedures and standards are left to rules or department decisions.
- Joint and several liability means a member could be responsible for the group’s full tax liability, not just its own share.
- The 50% rule for certain foreign-company income applies to taxpayers outside the required or elected method, but the bill does not explain why that share is used or estimate its effect.