New Limits on Police Face Coverings

Summary#

SB 369 is an introduced Texas bill that would amend the Code of Criminal Procedure and add provisions to the Penal Code and Civil Practice and Remedies Code. It would require law enforcement agencies to post a policy limiting officers’ use of identity-concealing facial coverings, create a criminal offense, and change some civil claims against officers. Its stated goal is to regulate facial coverings in law enforcement; the bill has not passed, so these changes are not yet law.

  • Each law enforcement agency would have to adopt and post the policy by December 1, 2027. The policy must prohibit officers from wearing facial coverings while doing their duties, except for the purposes listed in the bill.
  • An officer or covered person who knowingly wears a facial covering while doing law enforcement duties would commit a Class A misdemeanor, unless an exception applies.
  • An agency that does not maintain the required policy could not receive state grant funds during its noncompliance; pending applications for those funds would be denied.
  • For specified civil claims tied to an officer’s unlawful use of a facial covering, the bill would bar the officer from asserting official immunity and set a minimum recovery for a successful claimant of the greater of actual damages or $10,000.
  • The policy deadline is December 1, 2027. The criminal offense would start January 1, 2028; most of the Act would take effect September 1, 2027.

What it means for you#

  • Law enforcement agencies: They would have to adopt and post the policy. The bill requires the Comptroller to set rules for applying the grant-funding restriction uniformly among state agencies that distribute grants to local law enforcement.
  • Officers and people acting for law enforcement: The offense would cover Texas peace officers, officers from other states or the federal government, and people acting on behalf of those out-of-state or federal officers. The covering must conceal or obscure identity, and the person must knowingly wear it while doing their duties.
  • Exceptions: The offense does not apply to clear face shields or masks that do not conceal identity; protective respirators or surgical masks; breathing equipment needed for hazardous conditions or underwater use; or protective eyewear for retinal weapons such as lasers. There are also exceptions for authorized active undercover work, occupational health and safety requirements, safe operation of a vehicle, and protecting identity during a court proceeding.
  • People bringing civil claims: The special rules would apply only to claims against an officer for assault, battery, false imprisonment, false arrest, or abuse of process, arising from conduct while the officer wore a covering in violation of the Penal Code provision. The civil-liability rules would apply to claims accruing on or after January 1, 2028.
  • General public: The bill does not create a new agency or a process for people to apply for review of an officer’s conduct. The supplied material does not include the current versions of the amended laws, so it is not possible to verify how these provisions would change or overlap with current law.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated costs is included in the supplied material.

  • Agencies that fail to maintain the policy would lose eligibility for state grant funds during noncompliance, and pending applications would be denied.
  • The bill requires agencies to adopt and post a policy and requires the Comptroller to make rules, but gives no estimate of staffing or administrative costs.
  • Successful claimants in covered civil actions would be entitled to at least $10,000 or their actual damages, whichever is greater. The bill gives no estimate of potential payments or who would bear them.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain how the Comptroller would apply the grant restriction in individual cases or how an agency could challenge a finding of noncompliance.
  • “Other similar accessory” is not further defined in the bill’s description of facial coverings.
  • The bill does not set out how complaints or criminal cases would be investigated, or identify who would enforce the new offense.
  • The supplied material does not show how these rules compare with existing Texas law or other existing grant conditions.
  • It does not say how civil judgments against officers would be paid or whether any existing payment arrangements would apply.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a visible face can make it easier for the public to identify officers and hold them accountable.
  • Requiring agencies to post a policy would make their rules public, while grant consequences would give agencies a reason to maintain the required policy.
  • The listed exceptions preserve use of coverings for undercover work, health and safety, vehicle operation, and court proceedings.
  • A minimum recovery and limit on official immunity could give claimants a clearer remedy in the narrow set of covered cases.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill creates criminal and civil consequences but leaves some terms, including “other similar accessory,” open to interpretation.
  • The bill does not provide procedures for investigating or deciding whether an officer knowingly violated the rule, or how agencies can contest grant-funding consequences.
  • Denying state grants could affect an agency’s funding even when the underlying policy violation is disputed; the bill does not describe an appeal process.
  • The bill does not explain how the new civil rules would interact with existing laws or who would pay a judgment.