Large Cities Would Create Civilian Police Boards

Summary#

SB 405 would amend Texas’s Local Government Code by adding a chapter that establishes civilian complaint review boards in municipalities with populations of 200,000 or more. Its stated goal is to provide a process for investigating complaints about peace officer misconduct; that process would not itself guarantee discipline or prosecution.

  • Each covered municipality would have a five-member board. Members would be appointed by municipal and county officials and the police chief, and could not be municipal employees, public officeholders, or people with law-enforcement professional experience.
  • A person could file a written complaint without being the alleged victim. A board could also start a complaint by majority vote, and could choose whether to investigate complaints alleging specified abuses of authority.
  • For a complaint it chooses to investigate, the board must send it to the municipal attorney. The attorney must interview the complainant, the officer and witnesses, obtain relevant evidence, and complete the investigation within 120 days of receiving it.
  • The board or a panel of at least three members must determine each remaining allegation within 180 days of the board receiving the complaint. It must notify the parties and the officer’s employer.
  • The board may recommend discipline for a substantiated complaint. If the employer does not discipline the officer within 30 days after notice, the board must forward the case to the appropriate state or federal prosecutor.
  • Boards may issue subpoenas for relevant witnesses or records and may ask a court to compel compliance. The bill sets member pay and permits boards to hire staff.

What it means for you#

  • Residents of covered municipalities: You could file a written complaint even if you were not the person allegedly harmed. The board must take reasonable measures to protect complainants’ confidentiality and periodically update the parties.
  • Peace officers and their employers: The municipal attorney, not the board, would conduct the investigation. The board would make findings using a “preponderance of the evidence” standard (meaning more likely than not), and could recommend discipline for a substantiated complaint. The bill does not give the board power to impose discipline.
  • Municipalities: Each covered municipality would have to establish a board. The board could hire an executive director and other staff, and adopt rules.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not directly change taxes, fees, or benefits. It does require member payments and permits staffing and expense reimbursements.

Money#

The bill sets member compensation but gives no estimate of total public cost.

  • Board members would receive $150 per day of board business, capped at $5,000 per member per fiscal year, plus reimbursement for actual and necessary expenses.
  • Boards may hire an executive director and other personnel. The bill does not estimate staffing levels or costs.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the current Local Government Code provisions or other current-law sources, so what complaint processes already exist in these municipalities—and what this bill would change beyond adding this chapter—could not be verified.
  • The bill does not specify how boards choose which complaints to investigate, beyond saying they may investigate.
  • It does not set out appeal procedures, or explain what happens if the municipal attorney misses the 120-day deadline or the board misses the 180-day deadline.
  • It does not explain how the board’s process would interact with other investigations or complaint systems.
  • The bill requires appointment of initial members by October 1, 2027, and applies to misconduct occurring on or after that date. It would take effect September 1, 2027. As an introduced bill, it is not law, and passage is uncertain.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that residents would have a formal route to report alleged misconduct, including when they are not the alleged victim.
  • The investigation deadlines, written updates and required findings could make the process more structured and time-limited.
  • Subpoena authority could help a board obtain relevant testimony and records.
  • Civilian members could review findings without having law-enforcement professional experience.

Case against#

  • The municipal attorney would investigate, while the board would review the results; the bill does not explain how the board’s review would work if it disagreed with the investigation.
  • The board could recommend discipline but could not require it. A prosecutor referral after no discipline does not guarantee prosecution.
  • The bill allows boards to choose whether to investigate and gives few criteria for that choice.
  • The bill permits paid board work and staffing but provides no total cost estimate.