Cohabitation Rights Bill [HL]

Summary#

The Cohabitation Rights Bill [HL] is a private member’s bill that would create protections for some people who live, or have lived, together as a couple, and amend existing laws including the Administration of Estates Act 1925 and Fatal Accidents Act 1976. Its stated goal is to provide protections for cohabitants and make provision for a surviving cohabitant after a partner’s death. The bill is at committee stage and is not law; the supplied materials do not include the parent Acts, so current law could not be checked against the proposed changes.

  • A former cohabitant could apply to court for a financial settlement. The court could make an order if it finds that one person retained a benefit or the other suffered an economic disadvantage, and after considering listed factors.
  • Possible court orders include transferring property, making a property settlement, ordering a sale, or sharing pension rights.
  • The bill would change rules affecting a surviving cohabitant, including intestacy (when someone dies without a valid will), rights concerning the home, and claims for financial provision from the deceased’s estate.
  • It would also change provisions on fatal-accident claims and allow certain life-insurance policies to benefit a cohabitant or children of the couple.
  • The bill provides for opt-out agreements, but the supplied extract shows only some requirements, including that an agreement must be written, signed and dated.

What it means for you#

  • People who live or lived together as a couple: The bill would create a route to ask a court for a financial settlement after separation, but it would not automatically give every former cohabitant a payment or property share. Eligibility conditions apply, and the full conditions are not available in the supplied extract.
  • Surviving cohabitants: The bill would change some inheritance and estate rules and could give a surviving cohabitant rights concerning the home or a route to seek financial provision. The exact entitlements are not clear from the supplied material.
  • People making wills or opt-out agreements: The bill addresses agreements to opt out of financial settlement orders and lets parties vary or revoke agreements. The full legal requirements and effects are not shown.
  • Courts: Courts would have power to make financial settlement orders, including orders about property, sales and pensions. The bill does not appear to require a court application in every separation or death.
  • General public: The bill would not itself make all cohabitants legally equivalent to married couples or civil partners. The scope of each proposed protection would depend on the bill’s conditions.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated public costs, savings or other financial effects.

  • The bill would give courts powers to make orders involving property and pension rights, but the materials give no estimate of resulting costs or financial transfers.
  • No funding, staffing or administrative-cost estimate is supplied.

What is unclear#

  • The full eligibility rules for applying for a financial settlement, including any minimum period of living together or conditions involving children, cannot be verified from the supplied extract.
  • The bill’s definition of a qualifying cohabitant includes restrictions on relationship status and prohibited degrees of relationship, but parts of the definition and its exceptions are missing.
  • The factors courts must weigh, and how they would affect the amount or type of an order, are not set out in the supplied material.
  • The exact inheritance shares, home rights and estate-claim rules for a surviving cohabitant are not available here.
  • The full requirements for opt-out agreements, and how they interact with other agreements, are unclear.
  • The supplied material does not establish the bill’s full geographic extent or provide enough information to compare its changes with current law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address financial and inheritance problems that can arise when an unmarried couple separates or one partner dies.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives courts a way to consider whether one former partner retained a benefit while the other suffered an economic disadvantage.
  • The court’s power to choose among different types of orders could allow a remedy to fit the circumstances of a case.
  • The bill would provide for opt-out agreements, so the proposed financial-settlement scheme would not necessarily apply in every case.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the missing eligibility rules and court factors make it hard to know who would qualify or what financial consequences could follow.
  • The bill would give courts discretion to order transfers, property settlements, sales or pension sharing; that could create uncertainty for people dividing property or planning their finances.
  • The supplied text does not explain how the proposed protections would interact with existing inheritance and family-law rules.
  • It is unclear whether the opt-out process would give both people enough information and protection, or how disputes about an agreement would be decided.
  • No cost estimate or detail about court and administrative demands is available.