Summary#
The Strategic Litigation Against Public Participation Bill [HL] is a private member’s bill that would make provision about the misuse of litigation to suppress freedom of expression. It proposes changes under headings on early determination of cases and costs, and proposes repealing sections 194 and 195 of the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act. Its stated goal is to address misuse of litigation; that goal is not a guaranteed result.
- The bill’s supplied text does not include the clauses that would explain what “early determination” or the cost changes involve.
- It lists repeal of sections 194 and 195 of the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act, but the supplied text does not show the repeal clauses or their effects.
- The bill says it would extend to England and Wales and come into force on the day it is passed.
- The supplied status lists it at second reading in the House of Lords. It is not yet law, and whether it will pass is uncertain.
What it means for you#
- People and organisations involved in litigation in England and Wales: The bill’s headings suggest it would address early decisions and costs in some cases, but the supplied text does not show who could apply, what a court would have to decide, or how costs would change.
- People relying on the sections proposed for repeal: The bill lists those sections for repeal, but the supplied materials do not explain their current effect or what removing them would mean.
- General public: The stated goal concerns freedom of expression. The supplied text does not establish a new right, ban, or service, or show which cases would be covered.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The supplied material gives no estimate of public spending, savings, or legal costs.
- It does not explain whether the proposed cost provisions would change who pays legal costs, or by how much.
What is unclear#
- The operative clauses are not included in the supplied bill text, so the proposed legal tests and court powers cannot be confirmed.
- It is unclear who could seek early determination, when they could do so, and what process, deadlines, or appeal rights would apply.
- The text does not show how the proposed costs provisions would work or which parties they would affect.
- The text does not explain the current effect of sections 194 and 195 or the consequences of repealing them.
- Although the bill says it would start when passed, it does not say when or whether it will pass.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address litigation used to suppress freedom of expression.
- A possible argument for early determination is that it could allow a court to deal sooner with a case that meets the bill’s proposed test. The supplied text does not show that test or the court’s powers.
- Changing costs rules could be intended to address the financial pressure litigation can create. The supplied text does not show how the changes would work.
Case against#
- The supplied text is too incomplete to judge what cases would qualify or how courts would distinguish misuse from other litigation.
- It is unclear what safeguards would apply before a case could be ended early, or how costs would be allocated. Those details could materially affect people bringing or defending claims.
- The bill proposes repealing two existing statutory sections, but the supplied materials do not explain what protections or rules those sections provide or what would replace them.