Officer disclosures before trial

Summary#

HB 605, Peace Officer Disclosure Amendments, would have added a new section to the Utah Code; it would not have amended an existing Act. Its stated purpose was to require disclosures about potential Brady material before a peace officer testifies in a criminal trial. The bill failed, so it did not become law; its proposed effective date was May 6, 2026.

  • Before a prosecutor could call an officer as a trial witness, the officer would generally have to give the prosecutor a signed disclosure about the officer’s work history, conduct, credibility, and other listed matters.
  • The disclosure would include relevant context or explanation, and the officer would have to confirm under penalty of perjury that it was complete and accurate to the officer’s knowledge.
  • The officer would have a continuing duty to update the disclosure. A prior disclosure from within the last 12 months could be reused, but the officer would still have to provide case-specific information and updates or affirm there were none.
  • The prosecutor would have to provide the disclosure to defense counsel as soon as practicable, consistent with applicable laws and rules.

What it means for you#

  • Peace officers: If the bill had become law, an officer called by a prosecutor to testify at a criminal trial would generally have had to disclose information in categories including discipline and investigations; criminal and civil cases; court findings; evidence, reporting, and testimony issues; possible impairment; statements showing bias; and relationships, statements, or incentives connected to that case.
  • Prosecutors: They would have had to receive the disclosure before calling the officer to testify and provide it to defense counsel as soon as practicable. The bill does not set a fixed number of days.
  • Defense counsel and people accused of crimes: Defense counsel would receive the officer’s disclosure from the prosecutor. The bill does not specify a separate procedure for challenging a disclosure or a consequence for an incomplete one.
  • General public: The bill would not have created a new public-facing service or changed criminal penalties. It applies to a prosecutor calling an officer to testify at trial; it does not expressly cover every witness or proceeding.

Money#

The bill appropriates no money, and the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • Officers and prosecutors would have had disclosure duties, but the bill does not estimate the staff time or administrative cost.
  • No fee, fine, or funding source is specified.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “potential Brady material” or explain how much detail or supporting documentation each disclosure must include.
  • It does not set a firm deadline beyond “as soon as practicable,” or specify a form, review process, or oversight system.
  • It does not explain how sensitive information, such as health or treatment information, would be handled or protected.
  • The current Utah Code text was not supplied, so the existing disclosure rules and how much this bill would have changed them could not be verified.
  • The bill’s proposed start date was May 6, 2026, but it failed and did not take effect.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to surface information that could matter to an officer’s credibility or to the handling of a criminal case before the officer testifies.
  • Requiring officers to make and sign disclosures could give prosecutors and defense counsel a more systematic way to identify relevant information.
  • Reusing a disclosure made within the prior 12 months, while requiring case-specific updates, could avoid repeating every part of the disclosure from scratch.

Case against#

  • The required disclosures cover a wide range of personal, employment, and case-related information, but the bill does not clearly set limits on what must be included or how it would be protected.
  • The bill relies on officers’ own disclosures under penalty of perjury, but does not establish a process to verify them or resolve disputes about completeness.
  • The terms and timing are not fully specified, which could leave officers and prosecutors uncertain about what information must be provided and when.
  • The bill requires the work but provides no funding estimate or dedicated resources.