Affidavits could validate petition signatures

Summary#

HB 583, “Initiative and Referenda Signature Amendments,” would have added a section to Utah law; it would not have amended an existing section. Its goal was to let some people cure an initiative or referendum petition signature that a county clerk rejected because it did not appear substantially similar to the signature in the statewide voter registration database. The bill failed, so this process did not take effect under HB 583.

  • It applied only to the manual initiative and manual referendum processes.
  • A county clerk would have had to contact the person within two business days after rejecting the signature and explain why it was rejected.
  • The person could have the signature counted by delivering a signed affidavit no later than 31 calendar days after the clerk received the petition packet—not 31 days after the person was notified.
  • The affidavit would attest that the person signed the petition, provide contact details, and authorize the lieutenant governor and county clerk to use the affidavit signature for voter identification.
  • The affidavit would include a checkbox for voters with a qualifying disability that affects their ability to sign consistently. Checking it would require an alternate verification process under another Utah law.
  • An election officer receiving a timely, completed affidavit would have to scan the signature into the statewide voter registration database and count the petition signature as valid.

What it means for you#

  • People who sign manual petitions: If a clerk rejected your signature for not appearing substantially similar to the one on file, you would have had to return a signed affidavit by the 31-day deadline for it to count. The bill does not provide extra time if notice arrives late.
  • Voters with a qualifying disability: You could check the disability box on the affidavit. The bill refers to an alternate verification process in another section, but that section was not supplied, so its details cannot be confirmed here.
  • County clerks: You would have had to notify the person within two business days, give or explain how to get the affidavit, and not count the signature without a timely, completed affidavit.
  • Election officers: You would have had to scan a received affidavit signature into the voter registration database and count the petition signature if the affidavit was timely.
  • People using electronic petition processes: The bill would not have applied to those processes.

Money#

The bill appropriated no money. No publicly available information.

  • County clerks would have had to provide notices and affidavit copies or links; the bill gives no cost estimate or staffing amount.
  • An election officer would have had to scan and retain affidavit signatures in the statewide voter registration database.
  • The bill specifies no fees or fines.

What is unclear#

  • The current law section that governs signature review was not supplied. I could not verify how the proposed cure process would have differed from the full current process.
  • The bill does not say how a person must deliver the affidavit, or how the clerk would decide whether it is complete.
  • The deadline runs from the clerk’s receipt of the petition packet. The bill does not provide more time if the person receives notice close to or after that deadline.
  • The alternate verification process for voters who check the disability box is in another section that was not supplied.
  • No publicly available information on the cost of notices, affidavit processing, or database work.

Case for#

  • A signature mismatch would not automatically end the person’s chance to have their petition signature counted. The affidavit would provide a way to confirm they signed.
  • Requiring notice within two business days, with access to the affidavit, could help people learn about the rejection and respond.
  • The disability checkbox and required alternate verification process recognize that some voters may not sign consistently.
  • The bill sets a clear time limit for returning the affidavit and requires a timely, completed affidavit before the signature can count.

Case against#

  • The 31-day period starts when the clerk receives the petition packet, not when the person is notified. A person could have little time to respond if notice is delayed.
  • The bill requires clerks to contact people, but does not specify how many attempts they must make if they cannot reach someone.
  • The affidavit signature would be kept in the statewide voter registration database and authorized for voter identification. The bill does not explain how that signature would be protected or used beyond that purpose.
  • The bill does not state the costs of added notices and affidavit processing, or how the added work would be staffed.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1647674

    Passed7 members voted

    House Comm - Held

    FOR · 7

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    7For

    • Republican5
    • Democratic2

    0Against

    5 members were paired and sat out the vote.