Court stays tightened for capital cases

Summary#

HJR-28, “Joint Resolution Amending Court Rules Related to Capital Felony Cases,” amends Utah Rules of Appellate Procedure Rule 23B and Utah Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 27. Its stated goal is to change how courts handle ineffective-assistance claims and stays of death sentences. The resolution says it takes effect upon a two-thirds vote in each house; the supplied status says it passed the Legislature and was delivered to the Governor, but gives no vote count.

  • An appeals court may not send a case with a death sentence back to the trial court under Rule 23B to make factual findings on an ineffective-assistance-of-counsel claim. Rule 23B’s remand process remains available for other criminal cases.
  • A court generally may not stay or suspend a death sentence, but must issue a temporary stay for specified events, including a timely new-trial motion, an appeal, automatic review, or a first postconviction petition after direct appeal.
  • The resolution also requires temporary stays in specified first postconviction cases when counsel is appointed or appears, and when the court finds the person is pregnant.
  • It limits stays tied to later postconviction petitions and competency-to-be-executed proceedings, and sets out when stays must be lifted or expire.
  • While a stay is in effect, the person sentenced to death remains in the custody of the Utah State Prison warden.

What it means for you#

  • People sentenced to death: A stay would not be automatic for every motion or petition. For a later postconviction petition or appeal, a court may not issue a temporary stay unless it finds the claims are not barred, are potentially meritorious, and cannot reasonably be decided before the execution date.
  • People challenging a death sentence: Rule 23B would no longer allow a remand to develop facts for an ineffective-assistance claim in a case with a death sentence. The resolution does not say that this bars other ways to raise such a claim.
  • Courts and lawyers: Courts must issue temporary stays for the listed events, but generally cannot grant stays outside the resolution’s exceptions. A stay after counsel is appointed or appears for a first postconviction case must be lifted if no petition is filed before the limitation period passes.
  • People in other criminal cases: The resolution does not directly change the Rule 27 release rules for defendants serving other sentences. It does not create a new public program or change taxes, fees, or fines.

Money#

The resolution appropriates no money, and no cost estimate is provided.

  • Courts must handle the amended procedures, but the materials do not estimate any added staffing or operating costs.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include separate current versions of the two rules. This comparison relies on the deleted wording shown in the resolution.
  • The resolution does not estimate the time or cost of handling the changed court procedures.
  • It does not explain how a person sentenced to death would obtain a ruling on a stay request in each listed situation, beyond the specified conditions and deadlines.
  • The supplied status does not give the vote count needed to confirm when the resolution takes effect.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to limit delays in carrying out death sentences while still requiring temporary stays for specified legal steps.
  • The listed triggers give courts and parties clearer rules about when stays must be issued and when they end.
  • A possible argument for restricting Rule 23B remands is that the resolution treats fact-finding remands differently in cases with a death sentence than in other criminal appeals.

Case against#

  • One concern is that a person sentenced to death could have less time for a court to consider a claim if the claim does not meet the rules for a temporary stay.
  • The resolution bars Rule 23B remands for fact-finding in death-sentence cases. This could limit that particular way of developing evidence about an ineffective-assistance claim.
  • It is unclear from the supplied material how much additional court or prison work the new procedures will require, or what that work will cost.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1648030

    Passed68 members voted

    House/ passed 3rd reading

    FOR · 54AGAINST · 14

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    54For

    • Republican53
    • Democratic1

    14Against

    • Democratic12
    • Republican2

    7 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1644580

    Passed9 members voted

    House Comm - Favorable Recommendation

    FOR · 8AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    8For

    • Republican8

    1Against

    • Democratic1

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.