Falsification claims in protective orders

Summary#

Utah’s Protective Order Amendments amends the Utah Code and adds new rules about claims that someone knowingly gave false information to obtain a protective order. It adds a way for a respondent (the person a protective order is sought against) to ask a court to decide that claim, and sets conditions for make-up parent-time. The stated goal is to address protective orders; the law takes effect May 5, 2027.

  • A respondent may file a motion alleging that the petitioner knowingly falsified important information to obtain the order. The motion must be filed within 60 days after the hearing, and the respondent must prove the claim by clear and convincing evidence (a high standard of proof).
  • A court may award reasonable attorney fees and costs to whichever party wins that motion.
  • If the respondent wins and both parties are the child’s parents, the court may order up to 20 counseling sessions for the child with a therapist chosen by the respondent. The therapist decides how many sessions, up to that limit.
  • A parent who lost parent-time because of the falsification may seek make-up time. The court must award it only if the bill’s listed conditions are met, including that the underlying protective order was dismissed on the merits after notice and a chance to be heard.
  • The bill also amends rules on custody and parent-time and changes a definition. The supplied material does not include the current full text of the amended laws, so it is not possible to verify every change against current law.

What it means for you#

  • People involved in a protective-order case: A respondent may ask the court to decide whether the petitioner knowingly falsified important information to obtain the order. This is a motion, not an automatic review or penalty. The bill does not say that making the motion automatically cancels the protective order.
  • Parents: A parent seeking make-up time must show that a court found the other parent knowingly falsified information in the protective-order proceeding, that the parent lost time because of it, and that there was no finding of abuse or neglect against that parent. The underlying order must also have been dismissed on the merits after both parties had notice and a chance to be heard.
  • Parents who qualify for make-up time: The court must order time of the same type and duration as the time denied, to take place within two years of the make-up-time order. It may also include denied weekend, holiday, or extended parent-time.
  • Children and parents: Counseling is optional for the court, not automatic. The bill does not set who pays for counseling.
  • Courts: Courts would decide these motions and, if the conditions are met, make-up parent-time requests.

Money#

The bill appropriates no money, and the supplied material gives no cost estimate.

  • Courts may award reasonable attorney fees and costs between the parties; the bill does not require the court to do so.
  • The bill allows a court to order counseling, but does not say who pays for it.
  • Additional court workload or staffing costs are possible, but no estimate is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “knowingly” or explain how courts should assess whether information was falsified for the purpose of obtaining an order.
  • It does not set out further procedures, deadlines for deciding motions, or review or appeal rules for these new motions.
  • It does not explain how counseling costs would be handled.
  • The supplied material does not include the current full text of the amended laws, so the full effect of those amendments compared with current law could not be checked.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives a respondent a way to seek a court finding when important information was knowingly falsified to obtain a protective order.
  • The clear-and-convincing-evidence standard and 60-day filing limit may help restrict these motions to serious, timely claims.
  • Make-up parent-time is limited to cases with a court finding of knowing falsification, a merits dismissal after notice and a chance to be heard, lost parent-time caused by the falsification, and no finding of abuse or neglect against the parent.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the new motions could add hearings and prolong disputes between parties; the bill does not estimate the added workload.
  • A petitioner who made a claim that was not proven may still face a motion, even though the bill requires proof of knowing falsification and does not treat an unsuccessful petition alone as falsification.
  • The bill gives courts discretion over attorney fees and child counseling but does not explain how they should decide those matters or who pays for counseling.

Votes

5 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1656867

    Passed27 members voted

    Senate/ concurs with House amendment

    FOR · 21AGAINST · 6

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    21For

    • Republican20
    • Independent1

    6Against

    • Democratic6

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1652027

    Passed27 members voted

    Senate/ passed 2nd & 3rd readings/ suspension

    FOR · 21AGAINST · 6

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    21For

    • Republican20
    • Independent1

    6Against

    • Democratic6

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  3. Division No. 1652028

    Passed29 members voted

    Senate/ passed 2nd & 3rd readings/ suspension

    FOR · 21AGAINST · 8

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    21For

    • Republican20
    • Independent1

    8Against

    • Democratic6
    • Republican2
  4. Division No. 1643545

    Passed4 members voted

    Senate Comm - Substitute Recommendation

    FOR · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    4For

    • Republican3
    • Democratic1

    0Against

    5 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  5. Division No. 1643546

    Passed5 members voted

    Senate Comm - Favorable Recommendation

    FOR · 3AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    3For

    • Republican3

    2Against

    • Democratic2

    4 members were paired and sat out the vote.