Tax credits could be split, carryback allowed

Summary#

SB-315, “Tax Credit Modifications,” was a Utah bill to amend the state’s corporate and individual income tax credit rules for donations to the Carson Smith Opportunity Scholarship Program. Its goal was to let taxpayers choose how much of a credit certificate to claim and carry any unclaimed amount to another tax year; the supplied status says the bill failed, so it did not make these changes.

  • Under the bill, a taxpayer could claim any portion of the amount on a tax credit certificate, rather than the full amount.
  • A taxpayer could carry an unclaimed credit forward for up to the next three taxable years or back to the previous taxable year. The bill would extend this option beyond credits left over because they exceeded tax liability.
  • The credit would remain nonrefundable. The bill would not change the rule barring an individual from claiming a credit for a donation to the extent they claim that donation as a federal itemized deduction for that year.
  • The bill would take effect May 6, 2026, if enacted, and apply retrospectively to taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2026.

What it means for you#

  • Donors claiming the credit: If enacted, you could choose to claim only part of the amount on your certificate in a tax year and carry the rest forward or back. The credit would still be limited by the nonrefundable rules.
  • Individuals, estates, and trusts: The federal itemized-deduction restriction would remain.
  • Scholarship applicants and other members of the public: The bill would not change the scholarship program itself.
  • Everyone: Because the bill failed, it does not change current tax rules.

Money#

No publicly available information gives an estimated cost or revenue effect.

  • The bill appropriates no money.
  • It could affect when taxpayers use credits and, in turn, when the state receives income tax revenue. The size of any effect is not stated.

What is unclear#

  • The bill text shows that current wording limits carryovers to amounts exceeding tax liability, but the parent code sections were not supplied, so I could not independently verify current law.
  • The bill does not explain how taxpayers would report or administer a carryback of an unclaimed amount.
  • No estimate is provided for the effect on state tax revenue or administrative costs.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that taxpayers could better match use of the credit to their tax situation, rather than being limited to carrying over only the amount above their tax liability.
  • Allowing a partial claim could give taxpayers more choice about when to use a credit certificate.
  • The bill would preserve the existing three-year limit on carryforwards and allow carryback only to the previous tax year.

Case against#

  • One concern is that allowing any unclaimed amount to be carried between tax years could make the state’s tax revenue less predictable.
  • The bill does not give an estimate of that revenue effect or explain the administrative steps for applying carrybacks.
  • Because the credit would remain nonrefundable and the federal deduction restriction would remain, the bill would not remove all limits on using the credit.