AI pilots in schools under sandbox

Summary#

SB-322, the Educational Technology Regulatory Sandbox, would create a new chapter of Utah education law and amend parts of three existing code sections, including education reporting and provisions related to the Office of Regulatory Relief. Its stated goal is to allow time-limited AI pilots in public education while protecting students and gathering evidence; the bill failed and is not law.

  • The Office of Regulatory Relief would run pilot applications and monitoring. It would generally have to approve applications that meet the bill’s criteria, unless the State Board of Education rejects them for violating federal law. The office could approve a pilot that needs a waiver of state law if the waiver is necessary, documented, and preserves student safety and privacy.
  • Vendors would have to test AI systems for safety, report failures, protect student data, and delete student data within 90 days after a pilot ends, subject to stated exceptions.
  • Parents could opt their child out without academic penalty, inspect AI-generated records about the child, and request human review of student-impacting decisions. Students would retain ownership of intellectual work created with AI assistance.
  • Educators would retain final authority over grades and instructional decisions. The State Board would have enforcement powers, including suspending or ending pilots; immediate temporary suspension is limited to an imminent threat that is also a material legal violation.
  • A pilot could last up to three years without renewed approval. Statewide adoption would require State Board review and a recommendation, followed by authorization in statute by the Legislature.
  • The bill’s highlights also list an advisory council and a five-year sunset, but the supplied text does not include the provisions explaining those details.

What it means for you#

  • Schools and local education agencies: Participation would be voluntary, but a school or local education agency would need approval to run a pilot. It would have to meet the application criteria, keep records of parent notices and opt-outs, and ensure students who opt out have equivalent educational opportunities.
  • Parents and students in a pilot: Parents would receive annual notice and information about AI use, be able to opt out at any time, and request alternatives. Students could ask for human review before a student-impacting decision takes final effect and could contest it through existing school appeal procedures.
  • Educators: They could not use AI with students until completing required training. They would have to review and approve AI outputs before student-impacting decisions enter official records or materially affect grades, placement, or educational opportunities.
  • Vendors: They would face testing, privacy, reporting, contract, and disclosure requirements. The bill would also provide limited liability protection for good-faith compliance, with exceptions including privacy-law violations, violations of the bill, and gross negligence or willful misconduct.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The bill would not itself require statewide AI use. The public would be able to see summaries of vendor safety testing, while some testing details could be protected as trade secrets.

Money#

The bill says it appropriates no money. It requires government work and independent pilot evaluations, but no cost estimate is in the available material.

  • The State Board would have to ensure independent evaluations, and educator training would have to be provided at no cost to educators.
  • The Office of Regulatory Relief would have to administer applications, monitor pilots, and report on them. The bill does not specify staffing levels or the cost of this work.
  • No publicly available information on total implementation costs, vendor costs passed to schools, or possible savings is included in the supplied material.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied bill text ends during the independent-evaluation provisions. It does not show the full rules for the advisory council, the five-year sunset, or the listed technical and other amendments.
  • The parent Acts and full current law are not supplied, so it is not possible to verify how the amendments change existing requirements or overlap with current programs.
  • The bill requires rules on several topics, including crisis response and student AI use. The supplied text does not show the full rules or when they would be ready.
  • The text does not specify the cost or funding source for administration and independent evaluations.
  • Terms such as “age-appropriate” and “material changes” appear, but their full meaning or application is not clear from the supplied text.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that pilots allow schools to test AI for a limited time before considering statewide use.
  • Required safety testing, privacy protections, parent opt-outs, and educator review could help limit risks while pilots run.
  • Independent evaluations would be required to examine learning outcomes, safety, privacy, costs, and effects on different student groups.
  • Requiring a new state law before statewide adoption would leave that decision with the Legislature rather than the State Board alone.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill assigns substantial work to the state and schools without an appropriation or cost estimate.
  • A pilot could proceed with a waiver of state law, and the supplied text does not explain how many or what types of state-law requirements might be waived.
  • The bill relies on future rules and evaluation work to settle important details; those requirements could be difficult or costly to carry out.
  • The supplied text does not show how the advisory council would be chosen or what influence it would have, making its role hard to assess.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1650793

    Passed24 members voted

    Senate/ passed 2nd & 3rd readings/ suspension

    FOR · 24

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    24For

    • Republican18
    • Democratic5
    • Independent1

    0Against

    5 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1650027

    Passed4 members voted

    Senate Comm - Substitute Recommendation

    FOR · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    4For

    • Republican3
    • Democratic1

    0Against

    3 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  3. Division No. 1650028

    Passed5 members voted

    Senate Comm - Favorable Recommendation

    FOR · 5

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    5For

    • Republican4
    • Democratic1

    0Against

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.