Grants tied to outcomes in pilot program

Summary#

SB-324, the Outcome-based Investment Grant Pilot Framework, creates a grant framework and adds its repeal date to Utah’s repeal schedule. It was signed into law and took effect July 1, 2026. Its stated goal is to administer certain grants using measurable project outcomes.

  • The framework applies only when a legislative appropriation expressly says a grant must use it. The bill directs $9 million in one-time FY2027 funding to two grant efforts.
  • Grant applicants must submit a plan naming intended outcomes, measures, and an evaluation method before project work begins. An agency may not award a grant unless it finds the plan meets the required standards.
  • Grant recipients must take part in an independent evaluation. Evaluators must assess whether the project caused the planned outcomes, compare actual results with the plan, and report to the agency.
  • The Legislative Fiscal Analyst’s Office and the Governor’s Office of Planning and Budget must set evaluation standards. The Legislative Auditor General may review evaluations, and agencies must report annually to a relevant legislative appropriations subcommittee.
  • The Utah Board of Higher Education’s grant is intended to use a digital data inventory to measure educational or economic outcomes. The State Board of Education’s grant is for up to two local education agencies to run school-improvement pilots at one or more chronically under-performing schools.
  • The pilot framework is scheduled to be repealed July 1, 2031. Evaluation results alone do not require an agency to end grant funding.

What it means for you#

  • Grant applicants and recipients: Applicants for grants covered by the framework must provide a pre-analysis plan (a plan made before a project starts) and meet evaluation requirements. Recipients must participate in an independent evaluation. The bill does not set application deadlines, appeal rights, or a process for selecting recipients.
  • Students, educators, and local education agencies: The education grant may support up to two local education agencies. Its stated design includes measurable expectations for teachers and principals, and may fund enhanced compensation for those who meet them, coaching, planning time, and other supports. It cannot support general operations or replace existing funding. The bill does not guarantee that any school, educator, or student will receive a particular service or payment.
  • People who may benefit from the higher-education grant: The grant is intended to measure outcomes such as credentials, postsecondary persistence or completion, employment, earnings, and income stability. The bill does not create an individual right to a grant or benefit.
  • Taxpayers: The bill appropriates one-time public funds for FY2027. It does not change tax rates or create a new tax or fee.

Money#

The bill appropriates $9 million in one-time FY2027 funding for the two grant efforts.

  • $4.5 million from the Income Tax Fund goes to the Utah Board of Higher Education.
  • $4.5 million from the Public Education Economic Stabilization Restricted Account goes to the State Board of Education.
  • Unless a specific appropriation says otherwise, an agency may use up to 5% of the funds appropriated for a covered grant to procure independent evaluations—up to $450,000 if applied to the full $9 million.
  • No estimate for administrative or other staffing costs is provided. No publicly available information.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say how grant applicants will be selected, how many grants the higher-education effort may make, or how long individual projects may run.
  • The higher-education grant refers to a digital data inventory, but the bill does not explain what data it will contain, who can access it, or how privacy will be protected.
  • The bill assigns evaluation-standard setting to the Legislative Fiscal Analyst’s Office and the Governor’s Office of Planning and Budget, but its definition of “independent evaluator” refers to standards established by the Legislative Auditor General. The relationship between these provisions is unclear.
  • The bill does not specify how evaluation results will affect future funding, except that results alone do not require termination.
  • The supplied material does not include prior text of the amended repeal schedule, so I could not verify other changes to that schedule against current law.

Case for#

  • Requiring plans and measures before projects start may make it easier to compare intended results with actual results.
  • Independent evaluation may provide a check on whether reported outcomes are supported by evidence.
  • Annual reports to legislative appropriations subcommittees may give lawmakers information about grant activity and results when considering funding.
  • The education grant’s stated limits—no general operations funding and no replacement of existing funding—are intended to direct the money to the pilot rather than routine costs.

Case against#

  • Some important details are left to standards and later decisions, including acceptable measures, methods, and the required level of evaluation rigor.
  • A digital data inventory could involve sensitive information, but the bill does not set out privacy or access safeguards.
  • Independent evaluation costs can use part of the grant appropriation, leaving less for projects.
  • The bill requires evaluation and reporting but does not require funding to stop when results are weak, so evaluation findings may not change what gets funded.

Votes

5 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1655917

    Passed25 members voted

    Senate/ concurs with House amendment

    FOR · 19AGAINST · 6

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    19For

    • Republican18
    • Independent1

    6Against

    • Democratic5
    • Republican1

    4 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1650280

    Passed26 members voted

    Senate/ passed 3rd reading

    FOR · 21AGAINST · 5

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    21For

    • Republican20
    • Independent1

    5Against

    • Democratic4
    • Republican1

    3 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  3. Division No. 1649554

    Passed27 members voted

    Senate/ passed 2nd reading

    FOR · 18AGAINST · 9

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    18For

    • Republican18

    9Against

    • Democratic5
    • Republican3
    • Independent1

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  4. Division No. 1647356

    Passed6 members voted

    Senate Comm - Substitute Recommendation

    FOR · 6

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    6For

    • Republican3
    • Democratic2
    • Independent1

    0Against

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  5. Division No. 1647357

    Passed7 members voted

    Senate Comm - Favorable Recommendation

    FOR · 7

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    7For

    • Republican4
    • Democratic2
    • Independent1

    0Against