Community Amenity Contribution to accelerate project

Summary#

Vancouver City Council adopted a change to the conditions for a rezoning approved in principle for 4339–4387 Cambie Street and 506 West 27th Avenue. The change revises the Community Amenity Contribution (CAC) calculation and adds tenant-support requirements; it does not enact the rezoning by-law. The stated goal is to support the project’s viability and timely delivery of housing.

  • If the rezoning by-law is enacted within 24 months of this decision, and the applicant has met all conditions, the CAC will be $1.95 million. If not, it rises in steps to a maximum of $4 million.
  • The applicant must provide a Tenant Relocation Plan with additional help for eligible tenants in four existing secondary-rental units to find new housing.
  • The project approved in principle is a nine-storey mixed-use building with 148 strata homes, ground-floor commercial space, a height of 28.7 metres and density of 3.6 FSR (floor space ratio).
  • The change does not alter the development cost levies or public-art contribution already secured. It does not itself enact the rezoning or give the applicant a legal right to have it enacted.

What it means for you#

  • Eligible tenants: The applicant must provide added help to find housing, based on tenants’ stated needs. For tenants who meet income eligibility, proposed housing must have rent no more than 20% below city-wide average rents. Low-income tenants and tenants facing other barriers, including seniors, must be assisted in securing a permanent affordable, accessible or otherwise appropriate option, as applicable under the City’s Tenant Relocation and Protection Policy.
  • Tenants seeking a home in the new building: The project is for strata housing, not rental housing. The report says tenants will not be offered a right to return to the new building.
  • Applicant and City: The applicant’s CAC depends on when the City enacts the rezoning by-law. Council’s decision does not require the City to enact it, and costs incurred by the owner remain at the owner’s risk.
  • Other residents: The decision does not change the approved-in-principle building’s size or housing type.

Money#

The City’s cost estimate is not provided; the applicant’s CAC may be lower than the previously approved $4 million.

  • CAC is $1.95 million if all enactment conditions are met and the by-law is enacted within 24 months of the decision. If enactment takes longer, the amount rises by $250,000 every three months, to a maximum of $4 million at about 48 months.
  • Development cost levies and the public-art contribution are unchanged.
  • The CAC will support delivery of the Cambie Corridor Plan Benefits Strategy, as before.

What is unclear#

  • The adopted motion refers to Appendix A for the exact revised conditions, but that appendix is not included in the supplied material. The full wording of the binding conditions could not be verified.
  • The material does not explain how tenant income eligibility will be assessed, how housing options will be judged appropriate, or what happens if suitable housing cannot be secured.
  • The actual CAC amount depends on whether and when the City enacts the rezoning by-law; the decision does not set an enactment date.
  • No publicly available information is provided about the City’s administrative costs or the value of the unchanged development cost levies and public-art contribution.

Case for#

  • City staff say the lower CAC could help the project proceed in current market conditions and support timely delivery of the 148 approved-in-principle homes.
  • The stepped CAC gives the applicant a financial incentive to complete the rezoning conditions and seek enactment sooner, while allowing the amount to rise toward $4 million if enactment takes longer.
  • The added tenant supports address the fact that the strata project will not provide rental homes for existing tenants to return to.

Case against#

  • The City could receive $1.95 million rather than the previously secured $4 million CAC if the project meets the conditions and is enacted within 24 months.
  • The new homes are strata, so tenants in the existing rental units will not have a right to return to the development. The decision relies on assistance finding other housing instead.
  • The supplied material does not show how the added tenant-support requirements will be enforced or what remedy applies if appropriate housing is not secured.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 11915

    Passed11 members voted

    Council: 22. Modification to Conditions of By-law Enactment for CD-1 Rezoning: 4339-4387 Cambie Street and 506 West 27th Avenue

    FOR · 11

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    11For

    • ABC Vancouver7
    • Green1
    • COPE1
    • OneCity Vancouver1
    • Vote Vancouver1

    0Against