Council rejects subdivision change for three parcels

Summary#

Vancouver City Council refused an application to change the subdivision category for 1842, 1868 and 1878 West 37th Avenue. The decision leaves Subdivision By-law No. 5208 unchanged for these properties. City staff said the category E designation was intended to reflect the area’s pattern of larger parcels.

  • The three properties remain in subdivision category E; they will not gain the potential to split each property into two parcels.
  • Category B would have allowed smaller parcels, subject to later approval of subdivision applications. Council did not approve that change.
  • The properties’ R1-1 zoning and the housing options available under it are unchanged. Redevelopment still requires later permits.
  • At committee, Councillor Maloney’s amendment to approve the application and direct Legal Services to prepare a by-law amendment was lost. Council approved the refusal unanimously on July 28, 2026.

What it means for you#

  • Property owners: The three properties cannot use this application to gain subdivision potential. City staff say each may still be redeveloped under existing R1-1 zoning, subject to permit applications.
  • Nearby residents: No subdivision or new housing project was approved by this decision. The report says future redevelopment could still include housing such as a multiplex under the existing zoning.
  • General public: The decision changes neither the zoning nor the subdivision rules for other properties.

Money#

The City report says there are no financial implications associated with the recommendation to refuse the application.

  • No cost estimate for any future redevelopment is given.

What is unclear#

  • No specific redevelopment plan was approved. The number and type of homes on any future project would depend on later applications and decisions.
  • The report does not quantify the traffic, parking, tree, noise or privacy effects raised in public comments.
  • The decision does not resolve how any future development or permit application would be assessed beyond the general process described in the report.

Case for#

  • The owners sought the change to create future subdivision potential and said they intended to redevelop the resulting parcels for multi-generational living.
  • City staff’s report says subdivision could allow six parcels instead of three. If each were later approved for a multiplex, the report says 18 to 24 strata homes could be proposed, compared with 12 to 18 on the three existing parcels.

Case against#

  • City staff recommended refusal because the surrounding south side of the block has larger parcels, and staff said category E reflects that pattern.
  • Staff said approval could set a precedent for smaller parcels in an area with larger lots. It could also add driveways, which staff linked to traffic and pedestrian impacts.
  • Five responses to the City’s notification opposed the application. The concerns included traffic, parking, loss of mature trees and changes to neighbourhood character. Two speakers at the committee meeting spoke against the report’s recommendations to refuse the application.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 11773

    Passed9 members voted

    Standing Committee on City Finance and Services: Report 2. Proposed Amendment to Subdivision By-law No. 5208 – Reclassification of 1842, 1868 and 1878 West 37th Avenue (abstentions count as votes in favour under the Vancouver Charter)

    FOR · 8AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    8For

    • ABC Vancouver7
    • COPE1

    1Against

    • OneCity Vancouver1

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 11771

    Defeated9 members voted

    Standing Committee on City Finance and Services: Report 2. Proposed Amendment to Subdivision By-law No. 5208 – Reclassification of 1842, 1868 and 1878 West 37th Avenue - Lost (abstentions count as votes in favour under the Vancouver Charter)

    AGAINST · 8FOR · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    8Against

    • ABC Vancouver7
    • COPE1

    1For

    • OneCity Vancouver1

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.