Solar Operations Would Need Active Farming

Summary#

HB 1091, “Right to farm; solar panels,” would amend and reenact a definition in the Code of Virginia’s right-to-farm chapter. It would expressly include some solar-electricity operations in the definition of “agricultural operation.” The goal signaled by the title is to address how solar panels fit within right-to-farm law; the bill does not state a broader goal. As supplied, it is introduced and is not law, so passage is uncertain.

  • A solar-electricity operation would count as an “agricultural operation” only if it operates at the same time as bona fide production of crops, animals, or fowl.
  • The bill changes a definition used in the chapter; the supplied text does not itself create a new right, permit, subsidy, or payment.
  • The supplied material does not include the rest of the chapter or the current version of the amended section, so it is not possible to verify which parts of the wording are new or what legal protections would apply.

What it means for you#

  • Farms combining solar power and production: If enacted, their solar-electricity operation would fit the bill’s definition only while bona fide crop, animal, or fowl production also takes place. How that definition affects them depends on other provisions of the chapter.
  • Other solar operators: A solar installation without the required concurrent agricultural production is not included by this new wording.
  • General public: The bill text does not directly change taxes, fees, or public services.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The supplied text does not appropriate money or set a fee, fine, or payment.

What is unclear#

  • The current version of the amended section and the rest of the right-to-farm chapter were not supplied. The bill’s precise change from current law, and the consequences of being defined as an “agricultural operation,” could not be verified.
  • The bill does not define “concurrent” or “bona fide,” or set a minimum amount of agricultural production or limit on solar generation.
  • The text does not set a process for deciding whether an operation qualifies, or specify who would make that decision.
  • No effective date appears in the supplied text.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to recognize that solar electricity generation and agricultural production can take place on the same operation.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that including qualifying solar operations in the definition could make the chapter’s rules apply to them, rather than leaving their status uncertain.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain what legal protections or other treatment would follow from being included in the definition. Without the rest of the chapter, the reach of the change is unclear.
  • The bill sets no threshold for how much or how often crops, animals, or fowl must be produced. That may leave uncertainty about which solar operations qualify.
  • A possible trade-off is that the definition could bring solar operations within the chapter even though the bill does not explain how to distinguish substantial agricultural production from limited production.