Farm Rentals Face Fewer Local Bans

Summary#

HB 509, titled “Zoning; agricultural operations, rental of accessory dwellings,” would amend and reenact a section of the Code of Virginia about local regulation of agricultural operations. It would set out limits on local rules for certain farm activities and on prohibiting some rentals of accessory dwellings. The bill does not separately explain its goal. The supplied status says both “introduced” and “continued from last session”; it is not law based on the supplied material.

  • For listed farm activities—including agritourism, certain sales and food preparation, and activities usual and customary at Virginia agricultural operations—the text says localities may regulate them only if they substantially affect public health, safety, or general welfare. Any restriction must be reasonable and consider the farm’s economic impact and the activity’s agricultural nature.
  • In agricultural districts or classifications, the text says localities may not require a special exception or certain permits for those activities unless there is a substantial public impact.
  • For sound from those activities, local rules generally could not be stricter than the locality’s general noise ordinance. Outdoor amplified music is treated differently: the locality must consider nearby residents and adjoining property owners when permitting it.
  • A locality could not prohibit renting an existing accessory residential dwelling on agricultural-operation property for 30 days or more. This rule would not apply within a town.
  • The supplied text does not show which of these rules would be new. The current version of the amended section was not supplied, so the changes cannot be fully compared with current law.

What it means for you#

  • Farm operators: The bill text would limit local restrictions on the listed activities, subject to the substantial-impact condition and other limits described above. The text does not require an operator to offer any activity or rental.
  • Owners and renters of accessory dwellings on agricultural property: A locality could not prohibit rentals of an existing accessory dwelling for 30 days or more under this text, except in areas within a town. The bill does not create a rental program or set tenant rights.
  • Local governments: The text would restrict some zoning, permitting, and noise rules for agricultural operations, and restrict prohibitions on certain accessory-dwelling rentals. It does not create a new agency or office.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost is included in the supplied material.

  • The text sets no appropriation, fee, fine, or reimbursement.
  • It does not estimate any local administrative costs or savings.

What is unclear#

  • The current version of the amended law was not supplied, so it is unclear which provisions would change current law and which would continue existing rules.
  • The bill does not define “substantial impact,” “accessory residential dwelling,” or “existing” in the supplied text.
  • It does not explain how a locality would determine whether an activity has a substantial public impact, or how disputes would be handled.
  • The scope of the exclusion for areas within a town is not explained.
  • No start date or implementation process is provided. No publicly available information.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to limit local rules that could restrict farm-related activities, while still allowing restrictions where there is a substantial impact on public health, safety, or general welfare.
  • Considering a restriction’s economic impact and the activity’s agricultural nature could help account for the circumstances of farm operations.
  • Allowing rentals of existing accessory dwellings for 30 days or more could give owners another permitted use for those dwellings.

Case against#

  • One concern is that limiting local authority could make it harder for localities to address effects they consider important, especially because the bill does not define “substantial impact.”
  • The rental rule has no stated health, safety, or similar exception, and its terms are not defined in the supplied text.
  • The town exception means the rental rule would not apply everywhere, but the bill does not explain the boundary or why it is drawn that way.
  • Without the current law, readers cannot tell how much of the bill would change existing local rules.