Courts Would Offer Fine Payment Plans

Summary#

HB 1142, “Deferred or installment payment agreements; outstanding court-assessed fines, fees, taxes, or costs,” would amend and reenact Virginia Code § 19.2-354.1. Its stated goal is to set rules for payment agreements for court-assessed fines and costs. The supplied status says it passed the Virginia House of Delegates; the material does not show that it became law.

  • Courts would have to tell defendants about payment agreements and offer them a deferred, modified deferred, or installment agreement.
  • Courts could not refuse that opportunity for any of five listed reasons, including a prior default, the amount owed, or referral of the debt for collection.
  • Courts would have to consider a defendant’s financial resources and obligations when setting payment amounts and time. A defendant owing money in several cases in one court could generally have those debts combined.
  • People whose only financial resource is Social Security or Supplemental Security Income (SSI) would be exempt from payments at least until they have another resource. Their benefits could not be counted as available money for setting payment terms.
  • A defendant sentenced to active incarceration would have to receive a deferred agreement for fines and costs covered by the bill. Its due date could be no earlier than 180 days after the incarceration ends.
  • The bill’s operative text covers fines, court costs, forfeitures, and penalties, and includes restitution unless the court sets a separate restitution schedule. It does not set rules for taxes, despite the supplied title.

What it means for you#

  • People who owe court-assessed fines and costs: A court would have to offer you one of the listed payment agreements. It could not deny you the opportunity solely for a listed reason, such as a past default. This does not erase the debt.
  • People seeking installment payments: The court would have to consider your resources and obligations. It could offer payments of $25 or more based on ability to pay; payments below $25 are allowed if the court finds you indigent under existing law. The bill also permits a period with no payments followed by installments.
  • People who default: You could ask for a new agreement. The court would have to consider changed circumstances and could require a limited down payment. Under a new agreement, it could not require a payment history before restoring your driver’s license.
  • People whose only resource is Social Security or SSI: You would be exempt from payments at least until you have another resource. If you tell the court this is your only resource, your case could not be referred for collection under the cited law.
  • People sentenced to active incarceration: The court would have to set a deferred agreement, with payment due no earlier than 180 days after incarceration ends.
  • Courts: They would have to provide written notice, offer agreements, and follow the bill’s rules on setting and modifying them. If a community service program exists, they would also have to give written notice that it may provide credit toward the debt.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the supplied material.

  • Courts would have to carry out the notice and agreement duties; the bill gives no estimate of the related administrative cost or staffing.
  • The bill sets no new fee, fine, tax, or appropriation.
  • Payment terms can delay collection, including for people sentenced to active incarceration; the material does not estimate the amount or timing of any resulting change in collections.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of § 19.2-354.1 and explanatory notes were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which rules are new and which restate existing law.
  • The material does not show when the bill would take effect or whether it advanced beyond House passage.
  • The bill does not define terms such as “reasonable,” “good faith showing of need,” or “best efforts.”
  • It does not explain how courts would apply the payment rules in practice, or what process applies if a defendant disagrees with a payment decision.
  • It does not estimate how many people would use the agreements or how the changes would affect collection levels.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that payment terms based on a person’s resources and obligations may better reflect ability to pay than terms based only on the debt amount.
  • The bill would prevent courts from denying an agreement opportunity for specified reasons, including a previous default or lack of payment history.
  • The Social Security and SSI protections would keep those benefits from being treated as available payment resources under the bill’s rules.
  • Deferring payment for people sentenced to active incarceration could avoid a payment due date during or immediately after their sentence.

Case against#

  • The bill requires courts to offer agreements but leaves important standards, such as what counts as a reasonable payment plan, undefined.
  • The bill creates notice and decision duties for courts without specifying funding or estimating their administrative cost.
  • The bill would allow payment to be delayed, and the material does not show how that could affect the timing or amount of collections.
  • It is unclear how courts would handle cases where a person’s financial circumstances change or where debts involve different courts.