Defendants Wouldn’t Pay Publicly Funded Lawyer Costs

Summary#

HB 852, titled Indigent defendant; abolition of fees, legal representation, jury trial costs, report, would amend seven sections of the Code of Virginia. Its stated goal is to reduce fees and other financial assessments connected with criminal prosecutions, but it does not abolish all court fees. The bill has passed the House, but its main changes would take effect only if reenacted in both the 2027 and 2028 sessions.

  • Courts and clerks could not assess a person for amounts the Commonwealth or a locality paid for that person’s legal representation.
  • The bill would exclude legal-representation costs and jury costs from prosecution expense statements under one law. It also specifically excludes jury costs when a defendant waives a jury at least 10 days before trial but the Commonwealth or court refuses the waiver.
  • A separate cost-assessment law still lists “any jury costs” as an amount to assess. The bill does not clearly resolve how that listing fits with its jury-cost exclusions.
  • The Indigent Defense Commission, working with the Supreme Court’s Executive Secretary, must convene a work group to study criminal-case fees and recommend ways to reduce or eliminate them. The group must report by November 1, 2026, and November 1, 2027.
  • The bill rewrites existing sections, but the current Code of Virginia was not supplied, so the full difference from current law could not be verified. The text does not establish that all its rewritten rules are new.

What it means for you#

  • People charged with crimes: The text says no person may be assessed amounts the state or locality paid for legal representation. It does not remove other fines or court costs.
  • People facing jury trials: The bill says jury costs cannot be included in prosecution expense statements, with a specific rule for a refused jury waiver. But another amended section lists jury costs among assessable costs, so the overall effect is unclear.
  • Children and families in juvenile or child-welfare cases: The bill keeps provisions allowing some parents or other parties to be charged for appointed counsel or a child’s guardian ad litem (a court-appointed lawyer who represents the child). It does not abolish those charges.
  • Courts and public agencies: The Indigent Defense Commission and the Supreme Court’s Executive Secretary must organize the work group and submit reports. The bill does not create a new front-line service or a process for individuals to apply for fee relief.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill gives no estimate of any public cost, lost fee revenue, or savings.
  • Public bodies would have to provide the work group’s support and prepare its reports, but the text gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • If fewer legal-representation costs are collected from defendants, public revenue could fall; the amount is not stated.

What is unclear#

  • How the jury-cost exclusion works alongside the separate provision listing jury costs as assessable.
  • How the ban on charging people for publicly paid legal representation interacts with wording elsewhere that still refers to recovering some representation costs from convicted people.
  • How much of the rewritten language changes current law; the current Code was not supplied.
  • Whether other public funding would replace any revenue no longer collected, and how much that would cost.
  • The bill requires the work group to study fees, but does not itself set a broad fee cap or eliminate all criminal-case fees.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that people should not be charged for legal representation the government provides, especially when they cannot afford a lawyer.
  • Excluding jury costs when a defendant asked to waive a jury but the Commonwealth or court refused could avoid making that defendant pay for a choice they did not make.
  • The work group must examine collections, the burden on indigent people, and alternatives such as fee caps before recommending changes to other criminal-case fees.

Case against#

  • The bill does not say how public bodies would replace any lost collections, so costs could shift to state or local budgets.
  • Its jury-cost provisions appear to point in different directions, making the effect on defendants and courts uncertain.
  • The bill orders a study but leaves many fees in place; people seeking immediate, broad fee relief would not get that from the study requirement alone.
  • The bill does not specify how the work group will measure the burden of fees or how its recommendations would be acted on.