Written Estimates for Scheduled Care

Summary#

HB-1276, “Health care providers; required estimate for nonemergency health care services,” would amend and reenact an existing section of the Code of Virginia. The proposed text requires written good faith payment estimates for certain scheduled, nonemergency services and sets out related hospital price-transparency duties; its stated goal is to require estimates. The bill has passed the Virginia House of Delegates, but is not yet law.

  • Hospitals must make a machine-readable file of their standard charges available on their websites, following a federal rule.
  • A “hospital provider” must give a patient a written estimate if the patient or their legally authorized representative asks at least three days before a scheduled elective procedure, test, or other nonemergency service.
  • The estimate must use information supplied about the patient’s health plan, information reasonably available to the provider, and the provider’s standard charges. It must describe the service and related charges.
  • Hospitals and hospital providers must post information about the right to request an estimate in public areas and on their websites.
  • The estimate is not a contract or guarantee. The bill says the final bill may differ, including because the service changes or the health carrier processes the claim differently.

What it means for you#

  • Patients: You may request an estimate for a scheduled nonemergency service, but must do so at least three days before it is scheduled. The estimate is not a guaranteed price. Emergency services are excluded from the bill’s definition of nonemergency services.
  • Hospitals and providers: The proposed text requires estimates when the conditions are met, plus posted notice. It also requires hospitals to publish standard charges in a machine-readable file. A provider is not in violation of the estimate rule if the patient or carrier gives inaccurate or incomplete plan information, or the carrier later decides the claim differently.
  • Patients with health plans: The estimate is based partly on information about the health benefit plan. Providers are not required to determine with certainty whether they or an affiliated provider are in-network for a particular plan.
  • Current law: The bill rewrites an existing section. The current version of that section was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which requirements are new and which already apply. The text does not state that it changes health benefits, creates a new benefit, or sets a guaranteed price.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill gives no cost estimate, funding amount, or staffing figure.
  • It requires hospitals and providers to publish information, post notices, and prepare estimates, but the supplied material does not estimate the cost of those duties.
  • It sets no fee or fine.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the amended Code section was not supplied, so the extent of the change from current law cannot be confirmed.
  • The supplied bill text has duplicated subsection labels and words, including “participant patient.” This makes some wording unclear.
  • “Hospital provider” is used in the duties but is not defined in the supplied text. The bill separately defines “provider” broadly to include hospitals, physicians, and other authorized providers.
  • The bill does not specify how a patient requests an estimate, how quickly the provider must respond, or what happens if the estimate is not provided.
  • It does not set a method for resolving disputes about an estimate or explain how the estimate duty interacts with other estimate requirements.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that patients can get written information about expected charges before a scheduled service, which may help them plan.
  • Requiring use of plan information, available information, and standard charges gives providers specified bases for preparing estimates.
  • Requiring hospitals to publish standard charges and post notice of the estimate option may make price information easier to find.

Case against#

  • The estimate is not binding, and the bill expressly allows the final amount to differ. A patient may therefore still face a different bill than expected.
  • The three-day request deadline may limit the usefulness of the estimate for patients who learn about a service later.
  • Providers need not determine with certainty whether they or an affiliated provider are in-network, which may leave an important cost question unresolved.
  • The bill does not specify response deadlines, dispute procedures, or how estimates should be calculated when information is missing.