Civil Claims for Rights Violations

Summary#

HB 1314 would add a new section to the Virginia Code creating a civil action for deprivation of rights by a person acting under color of law. Its stated goal is to provide a civil remedy for those deprivations. The supplied material lists it as introduced, not law; the current text of the Code was not supplied, so I cannot verify how this proposal would change or overlap with existing remedies.

  • An individual who says a person acting under color of law deprived them of rights under the U.S. or Virginia constitutions or laws could sue that person for compensatory damages, punitive damages, and equitable relief.
  • If the plaintiff wins, the court may also award reasonable attorney fees and costs.
  • When deciding whether to award punitive damages, the fact finder must consider six listed circumstances, including use of a facial covering or crowd-control equipment, failure to identify as law enforcement, and intentional noncompliance with certain court orders. None automatically requires punitive damages.
  • A plaintiff could also name a supervisor responsible for directing or overseeing the person’s conduct. The bill does not state a separate standard for when that supervisor would be liable.
  • The action would have to start within four years of the alleged violation.

What it means for you#

  • Individuals alleging a rights violation: The bill would give you a civil action under this new section and list possible forms of relief. It does not set out a process for filing, proving, or appealing a claim.
  • People acting under color of law, including law-enforcement officers: You could be named as a defendant and face claims for damages or equitable relief. The bill does not say that every listed circumstance proves a violation or guarantees punitive damages.
  • Supervisors: A plaintiff could name you if you were responsible for directing or overseeing the conduct. The bill does not explain what responsibility would be enough to make you liable.
  • Public agencies and taxpayers: The bill does not make an agency itself a defendant in the text supplied. It also does not directly change taxes, create a public program, or require a new service.

Money#

The bill has no cost estimate; it would allow courts to award damages and, in some cases, attorney fees and costs.

  • A court could award compensatory and punitive damages to a successful plaintiff.
  • Attorney fees and costs would be an additional possible award if the plaintiff prevails; the court’s award is not mandatory.
  • The bill contains no appropriation or estimate of court, government, or other costs.

What is unclear#

  • “Acting under color of law” and “equitable relief” are not defined in the bill.
  • The bill does not set out the elements a plaintiff must prove, available defenses, or how the new action would interact with existing claims or protections. The current Code was not supplied, so existing law cannot be checked.
  • It does not explain how much weight the fact finder must give each circumstance when considering punitive damages.
  • It permits naming certain supervisors but does not specify the legal test for holding them liable.
  • The bill gives no effective date or filing procedures beyond the four-year deadline.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would give individuals a direct way to seek relief when someone acting under color of law deprives them of rights.
  • Allowing damages, possible attorney fees, and equitable relief could give plaintiffs more than one form of remedy.
  • Requiring consideration of the listed circumstances could make certain conduct relevant when a fact finder decides whether punitive damages are warranted.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the action and the covered rights are broad, while key terms and the proof required are not defined in the bill.
  • It is unclear how the new action would fit with existing remedies or defenses; the supplied material does not include the current Code.
  • Naming supervisors could expose them to claims, but the bill does not explain the liability standard.
  • The bill requires consideration of the listed circumstances without saying how they should affect the decision, leaving that judgment to the fact finder.