Police Chiefs Would Get Removal Hearings

Summary#

HB 1388, titled “Police chiefs; creates independent protections and procedures,” would add a new chapter to the Code of Virginia called the Police Chief Bill of Rights. Its stated goal is to establish independent protections for covered police chiefs; it would not amend or limit the existing Law-Enforcement Officers’ Procedural Guarantee Act. The supplied status lists the bill as introduced, not law, and the text gives no start date.

  • A locality could remove a covered police chief only for “just cause” (a substantial reason tied to the chief’s fitness for office), after written notice and a hearing.
  • A three-member panel would hear the case. The appointing authority would have to prove just cause by clear and convincing evidence.
  • If the panel finds there was no just cause, the appointing authority must reinstate the chief, restore the chief’s authority and duties, provide back pay and benefits, and remove references to the proceedings from the personnel file.
  • The bill would bar retaliation against a chief for using these rights, taking part in proceedings, refusing an unlawful order, or reporting a violation of law or policy.
  • The Virginia Association of Chiefs of Police, the Virginia Municipal League, and the Supreme Court of Virginia’s Office of the Executive Secretary, or their designees, must issue rules for the proceedings within 180 days after enactment.

What it means for you#

  • County, city, town, and public-college police chiefs: Before removal, they would be entitled to specific written reasons, at least five business days’ notice, and a hearing with an opportunity to have counsel, present and cross-examine witnesses, and ask for a public or closed hearing. “Removal” includes demotion, indefinite suspension, or another action that reduces rank, authority, or pay.
  • Appointing authorities: They would have to meet the bill’s just-cause and hearing requirements. A policy or priority disagreement alone would not be just cause without evidence of neglect of duty or a material violation of law or policy.
  • Police chiefs and appointing authorities: Either could appeal a panel decision to the local circuit court within 90 days. The bill allows the court to set aside a decision, order reinstatement with back pay, and award reasonable legal fees and costs.
  • Other law-enforcement personnel: The protections would not cover sheriffs and deputies, state police, other state or federal law-enforcement officers, private security personnel, or auxiliary police officers.
  • The bill does not create a new police department, change police services for the public, or set up a process for reviewing every chief’s conduct. It sets procedures for removal and related retaliation claims.

Money#

No publicly available information gives an estimated cost.

  • The bill requires named organizations and a Supreme Court office to develop rules, and creates panel and appeal procedures; it gives no cost or staffing estimate.
  • If a chief is reinstated after the panel finds no just cause, the appointing authority must provide back pay and benefits. The panel or court may also award reasonable legal fees and costs in specified circumstances.
  • The bill states no appropriation, fee, or fine.

What is unclear#

  • The rules on filing, panel standards, evidence, decisions, and confidentiality are to be written after enactment; their details are not in the bill.
  • “Just cause” includes listed examples but is not limited to them. How other conduct would be assessed is not specified.
  • The bill does not say how panel members would be paid or which governments or organizations would cover the costs of hearings and appeals.
  • The current text of the Law-Enforcement Officers’ Procedural Guarantee Act and other relevant current law was not supplied, so existing protections and how they compare with this bill could not be verified.
  • The text does not set out a start date or explain how the new rules would apply to a removal already underway.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a chief’s job could be at risk over policy disagreements. Requiring just cause and evidence could help distinguish those disagreements from misconduct or failure to perform duties.
  • A hearing with notice, counsel, and a chance to challenge evidence would give chiefs a defined way to answer removal charges.
  • The bill’s retaliation rule could protect chiefs who refuse unlawful orders or report violations.
  • The panel includes members appointed by different bodies, including one person who is not an active law-enforcement officer; this could provide more than one perspective.

Case against#

  • The bill could make it harder or slower for local authorities to remove a chief, even when they believe a change in leadership is needed.
  • Panel members are appointed through specified organizations and an office of the Supreme Court; the bill requires impartiality but leaves important selection and procedure details to later rules.
  • Reinstatement, back pay, and possible legal-fee awards could create costs for appointing authorities. The bill provides no estimate.
  • The bill does not explain how its procedures would interact with other existing protections, which could make it harder to know which rules apply in a particular case.