Rental Fees Would Face New Limits

Summary#

HB 1409 would amend and reenact two sections of Virginia’s Residential Landlord and Tenant Act. Its title concerns prohibited rental-agreement terms and landlords’ maintenance duties, but the supplied material does not state a separate goal. The bill is introduced and is not law; without the current sections or explanatory notes, it is not possible to tell which of the rewritten rules would be new.

  • Rental agreements could not require tenants to pay fees for maintaining the premises, including heating and cooling, pest control, trash disposal, common-area utilities, or mail and package delivery; fees for maintaining or securing common areas would also be barred.
  • Before a tenancy starts, the combined amount of a security deposit and premiums for damage and renter’s insurance could not exceed two months’ periodic rent.
  • A landlord could not charge for internet, cable, or other utilities or services above what the landlord pays for them.
  • A public housing authority could not charge a tenant for maintaining or repairing a dwelling unit unless the repair was needed because of the tenant’s action or omission.
  • The text also sets out landlord duties for fit premises, including repairs, common areas, utilities, mold, and smoke alarms. The bill does not establish which of these duties differ from current law.

What it means for you#

  • Tenants: If the proposed fee rules became law, rental agreements could not require the listed maintenance or common-area fees, or utility and service fees above the landlord’s cost. The two-month limit would apply to the listed payments made before the tenancy begins.
  • Tenants: A term barred by the bill would be unenforceable. If a landlord sued to enforce one, the tenant could seek actual damages and reasonable attorney fees.
  • Tenants in public housing: A public housing authority could charge for a dwelling-unit repair only if the tenant’s action or omission made the repair necessary.
  • Landlords and public housing authorities: They would have to follow the proposed restrictions on rental-agreement terms and fees. The text also lists maintenance duties, but the available materials do not show whether those duties would change.
  • Renters generally: The bill does not create a new housing program or guarantee that repairs will be completed within a set time.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill text would limit certain charges to tenants, but gives no estimate of any resulting costs to landlords or public housing authorities.
  • No public spending, savings, or funding source is specified.
  • The bill text states that tenants may seek actual damages and reasonable attorney fees in an action to enforce a prohibited term; it provides no estimate of how often this might occur or of related costs.

What is unclear#

  • Which rules are new: the bill reenacts two existing sections, but the current law and explanatory notes were not supplied.
  • When the changes would start; no effective date appears in the supplied bill text.
  • How terms such as “fee for the maintenance of the premises” would apply to charges that combine maintenance with other services.
  • Whether, and how, the proposed fee restrictions would interact with other existing rental charges or programs.
  • The text does not add application, complaint, review, or appeal procedures for tenants challenging a charge.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that tenants should not have to pay separate fees for basic upkeep and shared areas that landlords are responsible for maintaining.
  • The two-month limit could cap the combined upfront burden of a security deposit and the two kinds of insurance premiums named in the bill.
  • Limiting service charges to the landlord’s cost could prevent landlords from charging tenants more than the landlord pays for those services.
  • The public-housing exception would allow a charge when a tenant’s action or omission caused the repair, while barring other maintenance and repair fees.

Case against#

  • A possible trade-off is that landlords could have fewer ways to pass maintenance and common-area costs on to tenants; the bill does not explain how landlords might respond.
  • The terms covering maintenance and service fees may leave uncertainty about which charges are prohibited, especially when a charge covers several things.
  • The bill text does not explain how tenants could challenge a fee without a landlord first suing to enforce the rental term.
  • Because the supplied materials do not show what is already in current law, readers cannot tell how much of the proposal would change existing duties and protections.