Appeals Court Would Expand to 21 Judges

Summary#

HB 1485 would amend Virginia’s Code sections on the Court of Appeals of Virginia. The supplied substitute would raise the court’s stated size from 17 to 21 judges and change how en banc hearings (hearings by a larger group of judges) are composed; its stated goal is not included in the supplied text. The bill text provided does not include a change about summary disposition of civil cases, despite the title.

  • The court would consist of 21 judges, elected by the General Assembly as under the existing wording.
  • An en banc hearing would have at least 13 judges: the three judges originally assigned to the case and 10 selected through a randomized rotational schedule.
  • The Supreme Court of Virginia would have to make a rule for that randomized selection system.
  • The text appears to change “may” to “shall” for sitting en banc. The supplied text does not clearly explain how this wording relates to the existing rules on when a case goes en banc.
  • The bill would take effect September 1, 2026, if enacted. The supplied status says it passed the House; it is not yet law.

What it means for you#

  • People with cases before the Court of Appeals: If a case is heard en banc, at least 13 judges would take part, including the original three and 10 selected by rotation. The bill does not itself create a new process for requesting an en banc hearing.
  • The General Assembly: It would elect judges for a court with 21 seats rather than 17.
  • The Supreme Court of Virginia: It would have to adopt a rule for choosing the 10 additional judges.
  • People involved in civil cases: The supplied operative text does not change rules for summary disposition (deciding certain cases without a full hearing), despite the bill title.
  • Current-law comparison: The parent statutes were not supplied, so I cannot independently verify the full current law or all differences. The supplied text indicates the changes above.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the available material.

  • The bill would require a court of 21 judges, but it gives no estimate for salaries or other costs and makes no specific appropriation.
  • The Supreme Court of Virginia would have to make a rule; the text does not estimate the cost of doing so.

What is unclear#

  • The title refers to summary disposition of certain civil cases, but no such provision appears in the supplied bill text.
  • The text appears to replace “may” with “shall” for en banc sittings, but does not clearly state whether that requires an en banc hearing in particular circumstances beyond the triggers already described in the amended section.
  • The bill does not say when or how the four additional judges would be elected.
  • The Supreme Court’s selection rule, including how the randomized rotation would work, is not supplied.
  • The bill text does not show how much of the amended wording restates current law. The parent statutes were not provided for comparison.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a larger court could provide more judges to hear appeals.
  • Randomly selecting 10 additional judges for an en banc hearing could broaden which judges take part, while keeping the three judges originally assigned to the case.
  • A required selection rule could make the process more consistent, though the details depend on the rule the Supreme Court adopts.

Case against#

  • One concern is added public cost: the bill sets the court at 21 judges but provides no cost estimate.
  • A 13-judge hearing could require more coordination than a smaller panel. The bill does not explain how that would affect the court’s workload or timing.
  • The randomized selection system is left to a later rule, so its practical operation is not clear from the bill.
  • The apparent change from “may” to “shall” could affect when en banc hearings occur, but the supplied text does not make that effect clear.