Appeals Could Raise Unpreserved Issues

Summary#

SB-859 would amend and reenact Virginia Code § 8.01-384, which concerns preserving issues for appeal. Its stated goal is to set out when an issue may be raised on appeal despite no objection at the time of a trial-court ruling. The supplied material labels the bill introduced and referred to committee, so it is not law.

  • A party who objected or made a motion would not have to repeat it or ask the court to reconsider just to preserve the issue for appeal. A party would not be treated as agreeing to a written order unless the party expressly agreed in writing in an endorsement of the order.
  • Arguments made in a written pleading or memorandum, stated in a final order, recorded in a transcript, or included in an agreed statement of facts would count as preserved for appeal unless expressly withdrawn or waived.
  • The bill sets out two exceptions for an appeal when no objection was stated at the time: the party had no opportunity to object or the grounds were not then available; or the record shows a miscarriage of justice, or a material violation of a mandatory statute or Supreme Court rule.
  • The mandatory-rule exception would not cover rulings within the court’s lawful discretion, claims that evidence failed to prove an offense element, or claims about evidence being wrongly admitted or excluded. It also would not apply if the party sought or agreed to the ruling or expressly waived the rule.
  • Relief for a material violation of a mandatory requirement would be limited to correcting that violation; unaffected parts of the judgment, order, or award could not be changed under that exception. An appellant relying on either exception would have to identify it in the opening brief and point to the supporting facts in the record.
  • The Office of the Executive Secretary of the Supreme Court of Virginia would have to amend two Supreme Court rules to match the act. The changes would apply to appeals with notices filed on or after July 1, 2027.

What it means for you#

  • People involved in civil or criminal cases, and appeals from commissions or other tribunals: The bill would set out circumstances in which an appellate court may consider an issue even though no objection was stated when the ruling was made. It does not guarantee that an appeal will succeed.
  • Appellants: To rely on either exception, you would have to identify it in your opening brief and show where the supporting facts appear in the record. The listed limits would still apply.
  • Trial courts and the Supreme Court’s rules office: The rules office would have to amend Rules 5A:18 and 5:25. The bill does not specify the wording of those amendments.
  • The public: The bill concerns how issues are preserved for appeal. It does not itself change the underlying rights, penalties, or outcomes in civil or criminal cases.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the Supreme Court’s rules office to amend two rules, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • It specifies no appropriation, fee, fine, or payment.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of § 8.01-384 was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify how much of the bill restates existing law and how much would change it.
  • The bill does not define “miscarriage of justice” or “material” for the new appeal exception.
  • The bill does not explain how the Supreme Court’s rule amendments would work in practice.
  • The supplied material labels the bill introduced but gives an offer date of January 13, 2027, which is after the current date.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let an appellate court consider an issue when a party had no chance to object or could not yet know the grounds for an objection.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that a party who has already made an objection or motion should not have to repeat it or seek reconsideration just to preserve the issue.
  • The mandatory-rule exception is limited to violations that matter to the result, and any relief under it must be limited to correcting the violation.

Case against#

  • One concern is that terms such as “miscarriage of justice” and “material” are not defined in the bill, which may leave room for disputes about when an appeal qualifies.
  • The exceptions could lead to additional arguments in appeals about whether an objection was possible, whether grounds were available, or whether a mandatory rule was materially violated.
  • The bill does not provide cost or workload estimates for the courts or the rules office.