Disability-linked statements in interrogation restricted

Summary#

HB 1535 would amend the Code of Virginia by adding a section on when certain statements to law enforcement may be used in criminal cases. Its stated goal is to address admissibility of statements by people with developmental or intellectual disabilities; it is an introduced bill, not law.

  • In most criminal cases, a defendant’s statement to law enforcement during a pretrial interview or before counsel is appointed would be inadmissible if the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not), that the decision to speak had a direct and substantial connection to the defendant’s disability.
  • The rule would apply to defendants diagnosed by a psychiatrist or clinical psychologist with autism spectrum disorder, a developmental disability, or an intellectual disability. It would not apply to prosecutions for capital murder or an “act of violence” as defined in Virginia law.
  • A qualifying score on an assessment tool approved by the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities would create a presumption that the required connection exists.
  • The bill sets deadlines for suppression motions and hearings, and requires advance disclosure of defense expert information when the defense plans to use expert testimony. It also allows the Commonwealth to offer relevant evidence in rebuttal.

What it means for you#

  • Defendants: If the bill became law, you could ask a court to exclude a covered statement. The bill does not automatically exclude every statement by a person with a listed diagnosis: the court must find the required connection, subject to the assessment-based presumption.
  • Defendants in excluded cases: The new rule would not apply to charges for capital murder or an act of violence as defined in the cited law.
  • Defense lawyers: In circuit court, a motion generally must be in writing and filed with notice to the Commonwealth at least seven days before trial; the hearing generally must occur at least three days before trial. The court may allow a later motion for good cause and in the interest of justice. District-court motions may be raised in writing before trial; on the Commonwealth’s motion, the court must grant a continuance for good cause.
  • Defense and prosecution experts: If the defense gives notice and intends to use an expert, it must disclose the expert’s report—or a written summary of expected testimony if there is no report—along with the expert’s qualifications and contact information. The Commonwealth may present relevant, admissible evidence, including expert testimony, in response.
  • Defendants at hearings or examinations: Statements made at the hearing or during an examination disclosed under the bill could not be used against the defendant in later criminal proceedings over the defendant’s objection, except for impeachment (challenging credibility) or a perjury case.
  • The bill concerns whether statements can be used as evidence. It does not itself prohibit police from questioning someone or require a lawyer to be present.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires courts to schedule hearings and sets procedures for expert disclosures, but provides no funding or cost estimate.
  • The bill says time needed to schedule a circuit-court hearing under this section would not count toward the cited speedy-trial limit.

What is unclear#

  • The current Code of Virginia provisions were not supplied, so the existing rules and how much this bill would change them could not be verified.
  • The bill does not explain whether or how the presumption based on an assessment score can be rebutted.
  • It does not define “direct and substantial connection” or explain how courts should decide which assessment domain would affect a defendant’s decision to speak.
  • The supplied text gives no start date.
  • It does not set out detailed rules for conducting the assessment or resolving disputes about the diagnosis, test, or expert evidence.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to keep certain statements out of a prosecution when a defendant’s disability had a direct and substantial connection to the decision to speak.
  • A court would decide whether the required connection exists, rather than treating a diagnosis alone as enough.
  • The assessment-based presumption could give courts a defined evidentiary factor to consider.
  • The bill protects defendants from having statements made at the hearing or disclosed examination used against them later, with limited exceptions.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the assessment threshold may not, by itself, show how a particular person’s disability affected a particular decision to speak.
  • The bill leaves key questions—especially how the presumption works and what counts as a direct and substantial connection—for courts to resolve.
  • The deadlines and expert-disclosure requirements could add preparation and scheduling demands for both sides; the bill gives no estimate of those costs.
  • The exclusion does not cover the listed serious offenses, so defendants charged with those offenses would not receive this rule’s protection.