First-Home Savings Limits Would Rise

Summary#

HB 183, “First-time home buyer savings plan; townhouses, principal limits,” would amend Virginia Code sections 36-171 and 36-173, which concern an existing first-time home buyer savings account plan. Its apparent goal is to allow larger account balances and make clear that a townhouse fits the bill’s definition of a single-family residence. According to the supplied status, it passed the House of Delegates but is not yet law.

  • The bill raises the amount of principal eligible for account status from $50,000 to $100,000 per account. Only cash and marketable securities may be contributed.
  • It raises the limit on principal and earnings that may be kept in an account from $150,000 to $200,000.
  • It defines a single-family residence to include a townhouse, as well as manufactured homes, trailers, mobile homes, condominiums, and cooperatives.
  • The account’s stated use is to pay or reimburse a qualified beneficiary’s down payment and allowable closing costs for a home in Virginia.
  • The bill does not require financial institutions to identify these accounts, track withdrawals, or check whether costs qualify.

What it means for you#

  • People saving for a first home: The bill would allow a larger principal amount to qualify for account status and a higher combined balance of principal and earnings. To use the account, the beneficiary must live in Virginia at settlement and meet the bill’s eligibility rules.
  • People who previously owned a home: The bill’s definition generally looks at whether a person owned a principal residence during the three years before purchase. It also includes someone who previously owned a home jointly with a spouse and is now buying independently after the spouse’s death or the marriage’s dissolution or annulment.
  • People buying a townhouse: The bill’s definition includes townhouses. The current Code was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify whether that inclusion would be new.
  • Account holders: The bill’s text provides that interest or other account income is excluded from Virginia taxable income, subject to the cited tax-law provision. The supplied material does not establish whether this tax treatment would change.
  • Financial institutions: The bill does not make them responsible for deciding whether an account or expense qualifies, tracking the account’s use, or reporting or paying related taxes or penalties.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill raises account limits but does not require anyone to contribute money or set aside public funds.
  • Its text provides for an income-tax exclusion for account earnings, but no estimate of the tax revenue effect is supplied.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the Code was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which provisions—especially the townhouse definition—are new rather than existing law being re-enacted.
  • The bill does not provide a start date or explain how account holders would claim or document account status beyond claiming it on a Virginia income tax return.
  • It does not set out a process for checking whether withdrawals pay eligible costs or resolving disputes about eligibility.
  • No fiscal estimate is supplied for the tax exclusion or the higher account limits.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that higher limits let people save more in an account intended for a home purchase.
  • Including townhouses in the definition could make the plan’s coverage clearer for people buying that type of home.
  • The bill limits qualifying use to a beneficiary’s down payment and allowable closing costs for a Virginia residence.

Case against#

  • Higher limits may increase the amount of account earnings eligible for the stated tax exclusion, but the bill materials give no estimate of the revenue effect.
  • Financial institutions need not track withdrawals or confirm that expenses qualify, so the bill does not establish an institution-based check on how account money is used.
  • The bill gives no estimate of how many people may use the higher limits or how much the tax exclusion may cost.