Local rent caps allowed by ordinance

Summary#

HB 278, Local anti-rent gouging authority; civil penalty, would add a section to the Code of Virginia. It would let localities adopt rent-increase limits by ordinance; the bill’s stated goal is to support those local rules. It does not itself set a rent limit across Virginia.

  • A locality choosing to adopt an ordinance must set an annual rent-increase allowance of no more than 3%, publish it by June 1, and keep it in effect for the 12 months starting July 1.
  • For covered rental units, the ordinance must prohibit increases above that allowance and allow no more than one increase under the ordinance in a 12-month period.
  • Landlords must give at least 90 days’ written notice of a proposed increase, including any applicable exemption and contact information for the local board or equivalent.
  • The locality must establish an anti-rent-gouging board or assign its duties to an existing local body. The board must create rules for exemption applications and challenges, and a fair-return-on-investment exemption for necessary increases to offset higher operating expenses.
  • The ordinance must exempt specified housing, including units first issued a residential certificate of occupancy within the previous 10 years, school dormitories, and licensed nursing homes. A board may grant additional exemptions.
  • Localities must set a civil penalty for violations, payable to the locality. A tenant may seek enforcement, and a landlord who fails to comply with the ordinance cannot obtain an order for possession in a nonpayment-of-rent case.

What it means for you#

  • Tenants: If your locality adopts an ordinance, covered rent increases would be limited by its annual allowance unless an exemption applies. You could petition for review of a landlord’s exemption certification, alone or with a group representing at least 10 adversely affected tenants, and could challenge a board decision in circuit court.
  • Landlords: In a locality with an ordinance, you would have to follow its increase limit and notice rules. You could apply for an exemption. A fair-return exemption cannot be granted for a unit that is not brought into compliance with applicable building or housing codes.
  • Local governments: Adoption is optional. A locality that adopts an ordinance must set up or assign a board function, create local rules and procedures, and provide for penalties and enforcement.
  • People statewide: The bill would not require every locality to adopt rent limits, and it does not itself create a statewide cap or a new state agency.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • Localities that adopt ordinances would have to administer the rules, including notices, exemptions, challenges, and enforcement; the bill gives no cost estimate or state funding.
  • Civil penalties would go to the locality’s treasury. The bill does not set a penalty amount; the ordinance would set it.
  • Landlords would have notice and compliance duties, but the bill gives no estimate of their costs.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current text of the Code sections the bill refers to, so it is not possible to verify how this authority would interact with current state law.
  • The bill does not set a process, timelines, or evidence standards for exemption applications, challenges, or board decisions; local rules would supply those details.
  • “Fair return on investment” is defined as enough to maintain a stable net operating income, but the bill does not explain how that amount is calculated.
  • The bill does not say how a locality should choose an allowance below 3%, or how it would address overlap with other local or state rules.
  • The bill provides no start date. The supplied material describes it as introduced, not enacted.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that localities could set rent-increase limits suited to local conditions rather than having one statewide rule.
  • The annual limit, 90-day notice, and one-increase-per-year rule could give tenants more predictability about rent changes.
  • Exemptions, including one for fair return when operating expenses rise, could allow some increases while keeping a general limit in place.
  • Requiring code compliance before granting a fair-return exemption could link that exemption to basic housing standards.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves adoption to each locality, so tenants and landlords could face different rules depending on where a rental unit is located.
  • Local boards would have substantial work to define procedures and assess exemptions, but the bill does not set common standards or timelines.
  • The allowance is limited to no more than 3%, while a fair-return exemption depends on a calculation the bill does not specify. That could leave disputes about what increases are justified.
  • The bill gives localities enforcement powers and bars possession orders in certain nonpayment cases, but does not specify the civil penalty amount or many enforcement details.