Emergency Plans Would Include Tribes

Summary#

HB 349, titled “Emergency services and disaster preparedness programs; inclusion of federally recognized tribes,” would amend and reenact a section of the Code of Virginia governing the Department of Emergency Management. Its stated goal is to include qualifying federally recognized tribes in emergency services and disaster preparedness work. The supplied text does not show which wording is new compared with current law, so the extent of the change cannot be verified.

  • The Department would have to include qualifying tribes in listed planning, assessment, coordination, guidance, training, and response activities.
  • To qualify under the bill’s definition, a tribe must be within Virginia’s present-day external boundaries, be recognized by Virginia and the federal government, and have a contract or memorandum of understanding with the Department for assistance under this section.
  • The Department’s duties include coordinating emergency plans and assessments, providing guidance and assistance, determining emergency resource needs, and coordinating warning, response, and recovery work. Some duties involving tribes apply “as appropriate.”
  • The bill gives the Department authority to make contracts and agreements, including with tribes. It does not require the Department to make an agreement with any particular tribe.
  • The Department remains an existing state agency; the bill does not create a new independent body. It also says the Department cannot take direct search-and-rescue or missing-person operational responsibilities away from tribes or law enforcement.

What it means for you#

  • Federally recognized tribes meeting the bill’s definition: The Department would have to include them in the specified emergency preparedness and response activities. The bill does not set out how a tribe obtains an agreement or what assistance an agreement must cover.
  • State and local agencies: The Department’s listed coordination and planning duties would include qualifying tribes. The bill does not directly require individuals or businesses to take new actions.
  • General public: The bill does not create a personal right to emergency services or guarantee a particular response. The supplied text says the Department must maintain a warning system capable of notifying political subdivisions and qualifying tribes of an impending disaster within a reasonable time.
  • Current law: The parent Code section was not supplied, so I could not verify which of these duties already exist and which would change.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated cost.

  • The bill does not state an appropriation, fee, fine, or cost estimate.
  • It assigns duties to the Department and authorizes contracts and agreements, but the supplied material does not say how much staff time, funding, or assistance would be needed.

What is unclear#

  • Which specific duties or wording are new, because the supplied bill text does not show the current section or mark the changes.
  • How tribes would seek or negotiate a contract or memorandum of understanding, and what its terms would be.
  • Whether the Department would provide funding or other resources to tribes, and how much.
  • How the Department would decide when a tribal role or responsibility is appropriate.
  • The supplied status says the bill passed the House of Delegates; it does not establish that the bill became law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make tribal governments part of emergency planning and response coordination, rather than leaving them out of the listed state-level activities.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that including qualifying tribes in assessments, plans, training, warnings, and recovery coordination could help connect emergency work across governments.
  • The contract or memorandum-of-understanding condition provides a formal way to set up assistance between a tribe and the Department.

Case against#

  • The contract-or-memorandum condition means a tribe is not included under the bill’s definition unless it has an agreement with the Department; the bill does not explain how agreements will be offered or reached.
  • The bill assigns broad duties but does not specify funding, staffing, timelines, or how disagreements over roles would be handled.
  • Because the current Code section was not supplied, it is unclear how much practical change the bill would make.