Tribal sovereignty defined; consultation required

Summary#

HB 368, titled “American Indians, Virginia and federally recognized tribes; establishes definitions, sovereignty,” would amend many sections of the Code of Virginia and add a new chapter. Its stated goal is to recognize tribal sovereignty and set common definitions for state law. The supplied bill text is incomplete, and the current versions of the amended laws were not provided, so it is not possible to verify which of the other provisions are new. The bill has passed the House of Delegates but is not yet law.

  • The new chapter would define “American Indian,” “Virginia recognized tribe,” and “federally recognized tribe.” Under its definition, a federally recognized tribe must also be a Virginia recognized tribe.
  • It would state that Virginia acknowledges the inherent sovereignty of federally recognized tribes within Virginia’s boundaries. It also says the chapter does not alter or diminish Virginia’s or tribal sovereignty, or parties’ rights and obligations under state, tribal, or federal law.
  • The bill would change terminology and references to tribes in many state laws. Visible examples involve environmental permits and reviews, land conservation, and state boards.
  • The text includes a duty for the Secretary of the Commonwealth to designate an Ombudsman for Tribal Consultation, who would help coordinate consultation between tribes, state agencies, and local governments. Because the current law is not supplied, it is unclear how much of this duty is new.
  • The bill would require consultation policies for certain permits and projects in localities identified by the Ombudsman. If a tribe does not respond by the policy deadline, the bill says the consultation requirement is fulfilled.

What it means for you#

  • Tribes: The bill would put definitions of tribal status and an acknowledgement of sovereignty into state law. It does not change rights or duties under other law, and does not set out a general process for resolving disputes over authority.
  • Tribes and state agencies: The bill sets out a state consultation role and, for specified permits and projects in identified localities, consultation policies. The text does not require consultation for every state action.
  • People applying for cave permits: The text requires consultation before certain cave excavation or removal permits in identified localities. The permit rules and penalties shown in the bill are also included, but without current law it is unclear which are changes.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The bill does not itself create a general tribal benefit or tax change in the provisions provided. It includes a state fund and other duties, but the incomplete text and missing current law prevent a full comparison.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the available material. No publicly available information.

  • The text provides for reimbursement of expenses for members of a possible tribal recognition advisory board. It does not say how much this would cost; the Secretary may establish the board.
  • The Ombudsman and state agencies would have consultation and coordination responsibilities. The bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text ends before all amended provisions are shown. The full scope of the bill cannot be assessed.
  • The current versions of the amended laws are not supplied, so it is unclear which duties, definitions, and consultation rules already exist.
  • The bill does not provide a start date in the supplied material.
  • The Secretary’s annual report is described as covering the status of tribes, but the text does not specify what information it must include.
  • The consultation rules would set a response deadline, but the bill does not specify the deadline or how tribes and agencies would resolve disagreements about whether consultation was meaningful.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that common definitions could make state laws more consistent about which tribes and members they refer to.
  • Acknowledging tribal sovereignty in state law could support the government-to-government relationship the bill says Virginia seeks to maintain.
  • A designated Ombudsman and consultation policies could give tribes and state agencies a clearer point of contact for certain permits and reviews.

Case against#

  • The bill’s sovereignty statement does not explain how authority would work in specific disputes; it expressly leaves rights and obligations under other law unchanged.
  • Consultation is limited to specified projects and permits in identified localities. If a tribe misses the policy deadline, the bill treats consultation as fulfilled, even though the bill does not set that deadline.
  • The bill assigns coordination and reporting duties but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • Because the current laws and full bill text are not available here, readers cannot tell how much of the consultation and funding language would change existing practice.