New Diploma Pathway for Students With Disabilities

Summary#

HB 428 would amend and reenact Virginia’s law on high school graduation requirements. Its main change is to require the Board of Education to create an alternative pathway to a standard diploma for some students with disabilities; the stated goal is to make the pathway and the Applied Studies diploma count as standard diplomas for certain opportunities as far as practicable. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • The pathway would be for a student whose individualized education program (IEP) says the student has the knowledge and skills for a standard diploma but needs significant instructional, course-sequencing, or assessment accommodations or modifications.
  • The Board must set eligibility criteria and required documentation in regulations. Those rules must include a course sequence with IEP-documented modifications, ways to demonstrate proficiency aligned with Virginia’s Standards of Learning, and standard-diploma credit requirements with modifications allowed or required by the Board.
  • The Board must take all steps necessary to ensure, as far as practicable, that both this pathway and the Applied Studies diploma are treated as standard diplomas for specified education, financial aid, military enlistment, and state employment purposes.
  • The Department of Education must report each year to the Governor and General Assembly on implementation, including the number of students using the pathway and their postsecondary outcomes.

What it means for you#

  • Students with disabilities and families: The bill would require a new diploma pathway for students who meet its criteria. It does not set the detailed eligibility rules; the Board must do that through regulations.
  • Students seeking further opportunities: The bill directs the Board to pursue standard-diploma treatment for this pathway and the Applied Studies diploma when considering in-state higher education, FAFSA and federal financial aid, military enlistment, and state jobs requiring a standard diploma. It does not guarantee eligibility for any of these.
  • Schools and the Department of Education: The Board must make the rules, and the Department must report annually. The bill does not set application steps, decision timelines, or an appeal process.
  • Other students and families: The bill does not directly change other graduation requirements in the supplied text.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill requires the Board to make regulations and the Department to produce annual reports, but gives no cost estimate, staffing level, or funding source.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “significant” accommodations or modifications, or explain how the Board will decide whether a student qualifies.
  • The Board’s regulations will determine the course sequence, documentation, proficiency measures, and modified credit requirements. Those details are not in the bill.
  • “To the maximum extent practicable” limits the direction to treat the diplomas as standard diplomas; the bill does not explain what happens if an institution, federal program, military service, or employer does not treat them that way.
  • The supplied text does not include the current Code separately or mark which wording is new. It therefore does not let me verify every change to the existing section; the alternative pathway and its reporting requirements are the changes identified in the bill’s title and text.
  • The bill does not set a start date for the pathway or say whether the annual report must be public.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that students may demonstrate the knowledge and skills needed for a standard diploma while still needing significant accommodations or modifications.
  • The pathway would require proficiency aligned with the Standards of Learning and completion of credit requirements, rather than removing all academic requirements.
  • Better treatment of the pathway and Applied Studies diploma could help students pursue further education, financial aid, military service, or state jobs, if the relevant decision-makers accept that treatment.
  • Annual reporting could give the state information on how many students use the pathway and their postsecondary outcomes.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves key decisions to future regulations, so students and families cannot tell from the bill who will qualify or exactly what they must do.
  • Its direction to pursue standard-diploma treatment does not guarantee that colleges, federal aid programs, the military, or employers will accept these diplomas as standard diplomas.
  • The bill does not specify funding or staff for the new rules and annual reporting.
  • The annual report must go to the Governor and General Assembly, but the bill does not require public release or set measures for judging whether the pathway is working.