Multipurpose deeds would incur new fees

Summary#

HB 448 would amend existing Virginia law on financing statements, circuit court clerk fees, and recordation-tax exemptions; it would not create a new agency or program. Its apparent goal is to specify how circuit court clerks handle and charge for certain multipurpose deeds of trust and mortgages that include financing statements. The supplied status says it has passed the House, but it is not yet law.

  • When a multipurpose deed of trust or mortgage includes a financing statement and is identified on its first page as multipurpose, the clerk must use the fee schedule for multipurpose documents.
  • The clerk may not keep the original document as if it were only a financing statement.
  • The schedule is $200 for up to 10 pages, $250 for 11–30 pages, and $300 for 31 or more pages.
  • The schedule does not charge separate fees for each independent legal purpose in one document. Standard fees apply if multiple copies are submitted with a request to index them as separate legal instruments.

What it means for you#

  • People or businesses recording these documents: The clerk would charge the multipurpose-document fee if the document meets the bill’s conditions. The first page must identify it as a multipurpose deed of trust or mortgage.
  • Circuit court clerks: They would have to apply that fee schedule and would not keep the original as a financing-statement-only filing.
  • People recording other documents: The bill does not directly change the general recording fees or the rules for financing statements that are not part of a qualifying multipurpose deed or mortgage.
  • Taxpayers and property owners: The bill includes Virginia’s recordation-tax exemptions, but the supplied text does not clearly show what, if anything, it changes in those exemptions.

Money#

No public cost estimate or revenue estimate is in the supplied material.

  • The bill directs clerks to charge $200, $250, or $300, based on page count, for the specified multipurpose documents.
  • The bill does not estimate how many documents would be affected or how much fee revenue would result.
  • It does not provide a staffing or implementation cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied bill text has no change markings, and the current versions of the amended laws were not provided. So it is not possible to verify which wording in the fee and tax-exemption sections is new, beyond the apparent new rule on clerks’ handling of these documents.
  • The text does not say whether the fee direction would change what clerks currently charge in practice.
  • The bill does not explain how its amendments to the two versions of the recordation-tax exemption section would affect tax exemptions, if at all.
  • The text does not provide an effective date.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives clerks a clear rule for a document that serves both as a deed of trust or mortgage and as a financing statement.
  • Applying one multipurpose-document fee, rather than separate fees for each purpose, could make the charge more predictable for a single document.
  • Requiring the clerk to handle the original as a multipurpose deed or mortgage may help keep its recording and indexing consistent with that role.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the $200–$300 fee may be a substantial charge for people or businesses recording these documents; the bill does not estimate the financial effect.
  • The supplied material does not establish whether the fee would be higher than what clerks currently charge for these filings.
  • The bill does not explain what changes, if any, it makes to the recordation-tax exemptions, making that part of its effect difficult to assess.