Public Bodies Set Rules for Remote Meetings

Summary#

HB 463, titled Virginia Freedom of Information Act; definitions, meetings, quorum and electronic communication, would amend and reenact two sections of Virginia’s Freedom of Information Act. The bill sets out rules for remote participation by public-body members and for all-virtual public meetings; its title identifies the subject, but the text gives no separate goal statement. The current versions of the amended sections were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify how much of this wording would be new.

  • A public body would have to adopt a policy by recorded public vote at least annually before allowing members to participate remotely or holding all-virtual meetings.
  • A member could participate remotely for specified health, caregiving, distance or personal reasons, subject to conditions and limits.
  • Most public bodies could hold all-virtual meetings, but the bill excludes local governing bodies, local school boards and several other named boards.
  • All-virtual meetings would have to meet notice, public access, materials, public comment, technology and record-keeping requirements.
  • The bill would define “caregiver” and specify what “information” means in certain public-record exclusions.

What it means for you#

  • Public-body members: Under the proposed wording, members could request remote participation for a temporary or permanent disability or other medical condition; certain caregiving duties; living more than 60 miles from the meeting place; or a specific personal matter. Personal matters would be limited to two meetings per year or 25% of meetings, whichever is greater. The body’s policy would set the process for requests and decisions.
  • Public bodies: A body choosing remote participation or all-virtual meetings would have to apply its policy strictly and uniformly. The bill would not require a body to hold virtual meetings.
  • People attending meetings: For all-virtual meetings, the body would have to provide electronic access, share meeting materials with the public when they are given to members, and allow electronic public comment when comment is customarily received. If public access transmission fails, the body must recess until access is restored.
  • People seeking public records: The proposed definition of “information” would refer to content in a public record about a specifically identified subject. It would not require producing information that is not in a public record. The effect of that wording compared with current law cannot be verified from the supplied material.
  • The public generally: The bill does not directly change taxes, create a benefit, or establish a new public service.

Money#

No cost information is provided in the available material.

  • The bill would require public bodies that use remote participation or all-virtual meetings to adopt and maintain policies and meet access and record-keeping rules. The cost of that work is not estimated.
  • The bill provides no funding or staffing estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the amended sections were not supplied, so the bill’s changes compared with current law cannot be confirmed.
  • The bill leaves terms such as “other medical condition” and “personal matter” undefined; public-body policies would set parts of the request process.
  • The bill requires policies to explain how requests are made, approved or denied, and recorded, but does not set a decision timeline or an appeal process.
  • The supplied text does not state when the changes would take effect.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives members defined ways to take part when health, caregiving, distance or a personal matter prevents in-person attendance.
  • All-virtual meeting rules would require public access, meeting materials, opportunities for public comment and a recess if access fails.
  • Annual, public policies applied uniformly could make remote-participation decisions more consistent.

Case against#

  • One concern is that public bodies would need to meet technical and access requirements for all-virtual meetings, but the bill provides no cost estimate or funding.
  • The named exclusions mean some public bodies could not use the all-virtual option, even though most could.
  • The bill leaves key request terms and decision details to public-body policies, so the process may vary between bodies.
  • Because the current law was not supplied, readers cannot tell from these materials which safeguards or definitions are new and which may already apply.