State Land Transfers Could Support Coastal Storm Project

Summary#

HB 487, titled “Norfolk, City of; Marine Resources Commission to convey easement for certain property,” authorizes the Virginia Marine Resources Commission to transfer certain property interests to Norfolk for the City’s Coastal Storm Risk Management Project. It does not amend another Act. Its stated purpose is to make property interests described as necessary for Phase I available to the project; it does not require the transfers or construction. The supplied status says the bill passed the House of Delegates, but does not establish that it became law.

  • The Commission may convey permanent easements, temporary construction easements, and fee-simple interests (ownership interests) in subaqueous land, generally shown on listed Phase I drawings.
  • The Commission may also quitclaim any interest the Commonwealth may have in Newton Canal, also called Mahone’s Canal or Brambleton Canal, within a specified Norfolk property.
  • For either transfer, the stated consideration is $1 and mutual promises. The Commission must accept the terms and locations.
  • Transfers require consultation with the Commonwealth’s Chief Resilience Officer and the Attorney General’s Office, the Governor’s approval, and documents in a form approved by the Attorney General’s Office.

What it means for you#

  • City of Norfolk: If the transfers are made, the City would receive the property interests covered by the deeds. The bill does not require the City to accept them or set out the other promises involved.
  • Virginia Marine Resources Commission: The Commission may make the listed transfers, but is not required to. It must find the terms and locations acceptable.
  • State officials: The Chief Resilience Officer and Attorney General’s Office must be consulted; the Governor must approve the transfers.
  • Residents and property owners: The bill does not directly change individual property rights, taxes, or services. The actual locations and extent of the transfers depend on the referenced drawings and the final documents.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the supplied material; no publicly available information on the project’s total cost or the value of the property interests.

  • The authorized transfers would involve payment of $1 plus mutual promises; the bill does not state what those promises are or establish the value of the interests.
  • The bill does not appropriate money or specify staffing or administrative costs.

What is unclear#

  • The referenced Phase I drawings are not included, so the exact locations and extent of the land interests cannot be confirmed from the supplied material.
  • No publicly available information on the other promises, final terms, or timing of any transfer.
  • The bill allows a transfer of any Commonwealth interest in the named canal, but the materials do not say what interest the Commonwealth holds, if any.
  • The bill does not explain how the transfers relate to other permits, approvals, or parts of the City’s project.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that the City may need access to or ownership of particular state-held land interests to carry out Phase I of its coastal risk project.
  • The bill identifies the project phase and requires the Commission to accept the terms and locations, with review by state officials and approval by the Governor.
  • Authorizing transfers does not force the Commission to make them if the terms or locations are not acceptable.

Case against#

  • The bill allows fee-simple interests as well as permanent and temporary easements; the exact land and the extent of the transfers are not clear without the drawings and final documents.
  • A possible concern is that the $1 payment is stated, but the value of the interests and the other promises exchanged are not.
  • It is unclear what the Commonwealth’s interest in the canal is, if any, and what the practical effect of quitclaiming it would be.