Riders Could Yield at Some Stop Signs

Summary#

HB 661 would amend the Virginia Code, including sections on traffic lights and roadway riding, and add a new rule for certain riders at stop signs. Its apparent goal is to let people using bicycles and specified small mobility devices yield instead of stopping in some cases. The supplied status says it passed the House of Delegates; it is not yet law on that information.

  • At a stop-sign intersection, a person riding a bicycle, electric personal assistive mobility device, electric power-assisted bicycle, or motorized skateboard or scooter could yield instead of stopping only if each intersecting highway has no more than two motor-vehicle travel lanes, the rider is at least 15 or accompanied by an adult, the rider slows to a reasonable speed, and the rider stops for pedestrians and yields to other vehicles.
  • The bill also sets out ways for these riders to proceed through a red traffic light: the existing-style option of stopping for two light cycles or two minutes, whichever is shorter, and a separate option when the pedestrian signal for the parallel crosswalk shows “Walk.” Under the second option, riders must stop for pedestrians, yield to specified traffic, and go straight or turn right.
  • It also amends rules on riding position, riding two abreast, and electric personal assistive mobility devices on certain Department of Conservation and Recreation paths. The supplied materials do not show which of these rules would change from current law.

What it means for you#

  • People riding the listed devices: At qualifying stop signs, you could slow and yield rather than come to a full stop, but only if all four conditions are met. At a red light, the bill’s text provides the two options described above.
  • Pedestrians and other road users: Riders using these exceptions would still have to stop for pedestrians in the crosswalk and yield to vehicles as specified. The bill does not give these riders priority over them.
  • Other road users and the public: The bill also addresses roadway position and riding two abreast, but without the current Code text it is not possible to tell which wording is new.
  • The Department of Conservation and Recreation: The bill’s text says the Department must permit electric personal assistive mobility devices on bicycle paths or trails it designates for that use. Whether this changes current practice or law cannot be verified from the supplied materials.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill contains no appropriation or cost estimate.
  • The Department would have a stated duty about device use on designated paths, but the materials give no staffing or implementation cost.
  • The new stop-sign rule does not state a penalty. The text for the traffic-light section says violations of that section are traffic infractions punishable by a fine of up to $350; the supplied materials do not show whether that penalty would change current law.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the amended Code sections were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which parts of the red-light, roadway-riding, or path rules are new.
  • The bill does not define “reasonable speed” or explain how the number of motor-vehicle travel lanes at an intersection is to be counted.
  • The bill does not state an effective date.
  • The supplied text does not explain how the stop-sign exception would interact with other existing traffic rules or penalties.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a rider who can see that an intersection is clear may not need to make a full stop. The conditions require slowing, stopping for pedestrians, and yielding to other vehicles.
  • The red-light option tied to a “Walk” signal gives specified riders a way to proceed when that signal is displayed, while limiting them to going straight or turning right.
  • The rules apply to several named kinds of mobility devices, rather than only bicycles.

Case against#

  • One concern is that yielding instead of stopping may leave less time to notice a vehicle or pedestrian, even with the bill’s conditions.
  • The phrases “reasonable speed” and “no more than two motor vehicle travel lanes” may leave room for disagreement about when the exception applies.
  • The bill’s supplied text does not explain how the Department’s path rule would affect current access or what steps the Department would take to apply it.