Adult Websites Would Face 10% Tax

Summary#

HB 720 would add a new tax section to Virginia’s Code; it does not amend an existing tax section. It would impose a 10% tax on certain gross receipts of commercial entities operating adult websites. The bill directs the revenue to Virginia’s Behavioral Health and Developmental Services Trust Fund; that is where the money would go, not a guarantee of a particular result.

  • The tax would apply to sales, distributions, memberships, subscriptions, performances, and other qualifying content produced, sold, filmed, generated, or otherwise based in Virginia.
  • “Adult website” includes a website, application, or digital or virtual platform where a substantial portion of the content is material harmful to minors.
  • The Department would collect, administer, and enforce the tax using the same approach as Virginia’s retail sales and use tax, adapted as needed. The Tax Commissioner must publish guidelines, which would be exempt from the Administrative Process Act.
  • If a court found any provision of the bill invalid or unconstitutional, the bill says that provision would not be treated as severable from the rest.

What it means for you#

  • Commercial entities operating adult websites: If they receive gross receipts from the listed qualifying content based in Virginia, they would owe a 10% tax on those receipts. The bill does not say that the customer, rather than the entity, is legally responsible for paying it.
  • People who buy or access content: The bill does not directly impose a fee on users or change rules about who may access content. Whether businesses would pass on some of the tax through prices is unknown.
  • Virginia’s Behavioral Health and Developmental Services Trust Fund: It would receive the tax revenue.
  • Other businesses and the public: The bill does not directly change other taxes or create a new service for the public.

Money#

The bill sets a 10% tax rate but gives no revenue or cost estimate.

  • The tax would be calculated on gross receipts, not net profit, from the specified qualifying content.
  • Revenue must go to the existing Behavioral Health and Developmental Services Trust Fund.
  • The Department must administer and enforce the tax, but the bill does not estimate staffing or other administrative costs.
  • No publicly available information is provided on expected revenue or likely effects on prices.

What is unclear#

  • The bill relies on definitions of “material harmful to minors” and “substantial portion” in another section of Virginia law, but that section is not supplied here. Those definitions could not be checked.
  • The bill does not define “commercial entity” or explain when content is considered “based in the Commonwealth.”
  • It does not explain how the tax would apply to platforms with a mix of qualifying and other content, or to receipts from different kinds of transactions.
  • The Tax Commissioner must issue guidelines, but the bill gives no deadline or details about tax filing, review, appeals, or reporting.
  • The bill states no start date. Its passage is uncertain because it is at the introduced stage.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would direct revenue from specified commercial activity to an existing fund for behavioral health and developmental services.
  • The tax would fall on commercial entities operating adult websites, rather than directly imposing a charge on users.
  • Using the existing sales and use tax system to collect and enforce it may provide an administrative model, though the bill does not estimate the cost.

Case against#

  • The tax’s reach may be hard to predict because important terms and the connection to Virginia are not explained in the bill.
  • A tax on gross receipts could apply even when an entity’s costs are high; the bill does not provide exceptions or explain how mixed-content receipts would be separated.
  • The bill requires guidelines but exempts them from the Administrative Process Act, and it does not set out a detailed process for taxpayers to challenge decisions.
  • The nonseverability provision could make a court ruling against one provision affect the rest of the bill; the bill does not explain how that would work in practice.