Cybersecurity Volunteers Could Aid Organizations

Summary#

HB 83 would add a new section to Virginia’s Code of Virginia and create the Cyber Civilian Corps within the Virginia Information Technologies Agency (VITA). Its stated goal is to provide rapid-response cybersecurity help to eligible organizations. The supplied material lists the bill as introduced; it is not yet law, and it gives no start date.

  • VITA may select deployable volunteers and non-deployable advisors. An advisory board within VITA would review Corps policies and recommend qualifying standards; it would not be a new independent agency.
  • The CIO must set expertise standards, approve tools, track training and compliance, publish operating guidelines, arrange training, and contract with clients before providing help.
  • Eligible clients—municipal, educational, nonprofit, and critical-infrastructure organizations—may request help after a cybersecurity incident. VITA may deploy volunteers, but is not required to do so. An incident includes an exploitable vulnerability, even if it has not yet been exploited.
  • Volunteers and advisors must sign agreements, consent to background screening, and complete checks before training. A person with previous criminal history cannot be a volunteer; the CIO may allow that person to serve as a non-deployable advisor.
  • The bill sets conditions for volunteer and advisor immunity from tort claims (civil claims for injury or damage). It also lets VITA offer legal help or pay certain claims, but does not require it to do so.
  • VITA may charge clients fees to recover expenses, but cannot make a profit from them. Some identifying cybersecurity information would be exempt from public disclosure under Virginia’s Freedom of Information Act.

What it means for you#

  • Municipal, educational, nonprofit, and critical-infrastructure organizations: You could request Corps help after an incident, but the bill does not guarantee deployment. You would have to sign a contract with VITA, and VITA’s guidelines would explain client requirements and how it selects and prioritizes requests.
  • Prospective volunteers and advisors: You would need an invitation, a contract, screening and a completed background check before training. Volunteers could decline any deployment. A deployment would normally last seven days, unless VITA sets another period in writing; VITA could extend it in writing.
  • Volunteers and advisors on deployment: You would not be a Commonwealth employee, agent, or independent contractor, and the Commonwealth would not be liable for your personal injury or property damage. Volunteer immunity for harm to others applies only under stated conditions, including acting within authority and not causing harm through gross negligence or materially breaching the agreement.
  • Taxpayers and the public: VITA must provide appropriate training and may compensate volunteers for actual and necessary travel and living expenses, at its discretion. The bill does not create a guaranteed public service for every organization or require VITA to deploy for every request.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated cost.

  • The bill gives no spending estimate or dedicated appropriation. It requires VITA to provide training and to compensate volunteers for actual and necessary deployment travel and subsistence expenses, with compensation at VITA’s discretion.
  • VITA may set client fees to recover expenses, but may not make a profit. The bill does not set fee amounts.
  • VITA may pay for legal services, settle claims, or indemnify volunteers and advisors in specified cases; these payments are not mandatory.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current Code provisions on VITA. I could not verify how these new powers and duties compare with VITA’s existing authority or other programs.
  • The bill does not set a start date, funding level, Corps size, or number of organizations it could assist.
  • VITA’s required guidelines would explain eligibility and request procedures, but the bill does not itself set detailed decision rules, response times, or an appeal process.
  • “Previous criminal history” and the criteria for selecting clients are not defined in the bill.
  • The bill does not specify how client fees would be calculated, or how VITA would decide what travel and subsistence costs to pay.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that eligible organizations could request specialized help when a cyber incident affects them, including when a vulnerability is at risk of exploitation.
  • VITA would direct deployments and approve tools, while screening, training, contracts, and written deployment records would set safeguards for participation.
  • A volunteer Corps could give VITA a way to respond to requests without making volunteers full-time Commonwealth employees.

Case against#

  • VITA may decline or not initiate a deployment, and the bill sets no response-time standard. Organizations could have no assurance of help when they request it.
  • The bill gives VITA important choices over volunteer selection, client priority, tools, fees, and deployment. Many operating details would be left to later guidelines.
  • The bill does not set a budget, while requiring training and allowing expense payments and legal costs. The scale of those costs is unknown.
  • The bill exempts specified cybersecurity information from public disclosure and gives the Commonwealth and VITA broad tort immunity. The practical scope of the exemption and protections would depend on how they apply in specific cases.