Long-Sentenced Prisoners Could Seek Sentence Changes

Summary#

HB 853, “Petition for modification of a sentence; eligibility, procedures, report,” would add a new section to the Code of Virginia. It would let some people still serving prison sentences ask the circuit court that sentenced them to consider changing the unserved part of their sentence; the bill’s goal is to set eligibility and procedures for those petitions. The supplied status lists it as introduced, so it is not yet law.

  • The time served before applying would depend on the convictions: at least 25 years for the most serious listed offenses, 20 years for another listed group, and 15 years for other convictions. The lists include, among other offenses, murder, specified sexual offenses, terrorism-related offenses, certain offenses involving a mob, and child pornography offenses.
  • Eligibility would also require that the person not have filed a petition in the previous three years, had a sentence changed under this section in the previous five years, or filed more than two petitions under this section.
  • The original sentencing circuit court could grant a hearing, but a petition would not guarantee one. The court could dismiss a petition without prejudice at an initial review if it finds no good cause.
  • If good cause is shown, the court could suspend unserved time, make it concurrent with another sentence, impose probation, or otherwise change the sentence. It could do so despite a mandatory minimum, but could not make a term of confinement longer than the original term.
  • The Department of Corrections would have to notify eligible people, make reasonable efforts to notify victims, provide records, and convene a work group. The bill also sets court and victim-participation procedures.

What it means for you#

  • People serving sentences: If you meet the offense and time-served rules, you could petition the court that sentenced you. You would have to use a Supreme Court of Virginia form and give specific information, including why you seek a change. Filing would be free. A court could allow you to fix an incomplete form.
  • People seeking a sentence change: The judge would consider factors including age, rehabilitation, prison conduct, programs, health information, victim statements, reentry plans, and other relevant information. A decision to change a sentence would be discretionary, not automatic. The judge would give written reasons and explain the weight given to each factor.
  • Victims: The Department of Corrections would make reasonable efforts to notify you about a petition and hearing. You could review specified Department records and, if you choose, take part in a facilitated encounter with the petitioner. You could testify or submit a victim impact statement. The bill says you would not have to respond to a petition except if the court orders it.
  • Courts and public agencies: The original judge would usually hear the petition. The Department would have to send eligibility notices in each eligible person’s primary language and provide relevant records without charge. The bill does not require a person to give up this right in a plea agreement.
  • General public: The bill does not change sentences automatically or create a right to release. It would create a process for courts to consider sentence changes.

Money#

The bill requires agency work and free records, but no cost estimate is provided.

  • The Department of Corrections would have to notify eligible people, provide records, make victim-notification efforts, and convene a work group. The bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • Courts and the Department of Corrections would have added work. No publicly available information on the cost is supplied.
  • No fee could be charged to file a petition.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “good cause,” the central standard for dismissing a petition or changing a sentence.
  • It does not set out a complete process for handling petitions, such as how a person without a lawyer could get legal help.
  • It does not say how the broad access to Department records for victims would be limited or protected.
  • The bill does not provide a start date or an estimate of how many people might qualify. No publicly available information on these points is supplied.
  • The work group’s report is due by December 1, 2026, but the supplied material does not explain how that deadline relates to when the bill would take effect.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that people who have served 15 to 25 years could show how they have changed, while a judge—not an automatic rule—would decide whether a sentence change is justified.
  • The listed factors let the court consider rehabilitation, health, age, and reentry plans alongside the seriousness of the offense and the victim’s views.
  • The process includes victim notice and an opportunity to participate, while making clear that a victim is not generally required to respond.
  • Written explanations could make the court’s reasoning clearer to the person petitioning and the Commonwealth’s attorney.

Case against#

  • The bill allows sentence changes despite mandatory minimums and gives judges broad discretion under an undefined “good cause” standard. Outcomes could therefore depend heavily on how individual judges interpret that standard.
  • The process could add work for courts and the Department of Corrections, but the bill provides no funding estimate or staffing plan.
  • Victims could access extensive Department records, including risk assessments and case-plan information. The bill does not clearly explain safeguards for that access.
  • A court’s decision would generally not be a basis for appeal or habeas relief unless it was contrary to law, which limits review of decisions.